| Year | Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1923: 1 | Yankees | Babe Ruth | 100%
|
| 1927: 1 | Yankees | Lou Gehrig | 100%
|
| 1924: 1 | Senators | Walter Johnson | 100%
|
| 1925: 2 | Athletics | Al Simmons | 75%
|
| 1926: 5 | Athletics | Al Simmons | 75%
|
| 1927: 4 | Athletics | Al Simmons | 75%
|
| 1922: 1 | Browns | George Sisler | 75%
|
| 1923: 3 | Tigers | Harry Heilmann | 75%
|
| 1925: 4 | Tigers | Harry Heilmann | 75%
|
| 1926: 5 | Tigers | Harry Heilmann | 75%
|
| 1927: 2 | Tigers | Harry Heilmann | 75%
|
| 1926: 5 | Tigers | Heinie Manush | 75%
|
| 1928: 2 | Browns | Heinie Manush | 75%
|
| 1924: 4 | Yankees | Herb Pennock | 75%
|
| 1926: 3 | Yankees | Herb Pennock | 75%
|
| 1927: 4 | Athletics | Mickey Cochrane | 75%
|
| 1928: 1 | Athletics | Mickey Cochrane | 75%
|
| 1927: 3 | White Sox | Ted Lyons | 75%
|
| 1928: 3 | Yankees | Tony Lazzeri | 75%
|
| 1924: 3 | Indians | Charlie Jamieson | 50%
|
| 1922: 5 | White Sox | Eddie Collins | 50%
|
| 1923: 2 | White Sox | Eddie Collins | 50%
|
| 1924: 2 | White Sox | Eddie Collins | 50%
|
| 1926: 1 | Indians | George Burns | 50%
|
| 1925: 5 | Browns | Harry Rice | 50%
|
| 1928: 3 | Senators | Joe Judge | 50%
|
| 1923: 4 | Indians | Joe Sewell | 50%
|
| 1925: 3 | Indians | Joe Sewell | 50%
|
| 1925: 1 | Senators | Roger Peckinpaugh | 50%
|
| 1926: 4 | Senators | Sam Rice | 50%
|
| 1922: 4 | Yankees | Joe Bush | 25%
|
| 1922: 3 | White Sox | Ray Schalk | 25%
|
| 1922: 2 | Athletics | Eddie Rommel | 0%
|
| 1924: 5 | Tigers | Johnny Bassler | 0%
|
| 1926: 2 | White Sox | Johnny Mostil | 0%
|
| 1923: 4 | Browns | Wally Gerber | 0%
|
| 1928: 5 | White Sox | Willie Kamm | 0%
|