| Year | Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1931: 5 | Yankees | Babe Ruth | 100%
|
| 1932: 1 | Athletics | Jimmie Foxx | 96%
|
| 1933: 1 | Athletics | Jimmie Foxx | 96%
|
| 1938: 1 | Red Sox | Jimmie Foxx | 96%
|
| 1939: 2 | Red Sox | Jimmie Foxx | 96%
|
| 1931: 2 | Yankees | Lou Gehrig | 96%
|
| 1932: 2 | Yankees | Lou Gehrig | 96%
|
| 1933: 4 | Yankees | Lou Gehrig | 96%
|
| 1934: 5 | Yankees | Lou Gehrig | 96%
|
| 1935: 5 | Yankees | Lou Gehrig | 96%
|
| 1936: 1 | Yankees | Lou Gehrig | 96%
|
| 1937: 4 | Yankees | Lou Gehrig | 96%
|
| 1937: 2 | Yankees | Joe DiMaggio | 83%
|
| 1939: 1 | Yankees | Joe DiMaggio | 83%
|
| 1935: 1 | Tigers | Hank Greenberg | 78%
|
| 1937: 3 | Tigers | Hank Greenberg | 78%
|
| 1938: 3 | Tigers | Hank Greenberg | 78%
|
| 1931: 1 | Athletics | Lefty Grove | 78%
|
| 1933: 5 | Athletics | Lefty Grove | 78%
|
| 1939: 4 | Red Sox | Ted Williams | 78%
|
| 1931: 3 | Athletics | Al Simmons | 74%
|
| 1936: 5 | Yankees | Bill Dickey | 70%
|
| 1937: 5 | Yankees | Bill Dickey | 70%
|
| 1938: 2 | Yankees | Bill Dickey | 70%
|
| 1939: 3 | Indians | Bob Feller | 65%
|
| 1934: 2 | Tigers | Charlie Gehringer | 65%
|
| 1936: 4 | Tigers | Charlie Gehringer | 65%
|
| 1937: 1 | Tigers | Charlie Gehringer | 65%
|
| 1936: 2 | White Sox | Luke Appling | 65%
|
| 1934: 1 | Tigers | Mickey Cochrane | 65%
|
| 1938: 4 | Yankees | Red Ruffing | 48%
|
| 1939: 5 | Yankees | Red Ruffing | 48%
|
| 1931: 4 | Indians | Earl Averill | 43%
|
| 1932: 4 | Indians | Earl Averill | 43%
|
| 1936: 3 | Indians | Earl Averill | 43%
|
| 1932: 5 | Yankees | Lefty Gomez | 39%
|
| 1934: 3 | Yankees | Lefty Gomez | 39%
|
| 1932: 3 | Senators | Heinie Manush | 30%
|
| 1933: 3 | Senators | Heinie Manush | 30%
|
| 1933: 2 | Senators | Joe Cronin | 26%
|
| 1935: 2 | Red Sox | Wes Ferrell | 26%
|
| 1937: 5 | White Sox | Luke Sewell | 17%
|
| 1934: 4 | Tigers | Schoolboy Rowe | 17%
|
| 1938: 5 | Browns | Bobo Newsom | 13%
|
| 1935: 4 | Senators | Buddy Myer | 13%
|
| 1935: 3 | Indians | Joe Vosmik | 13%
|