| Year | Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1940: 3 | Yankees | Joe DiMaggio | 95%
|
| 1941: 1 | Yankees | Joe DiMaggio | 95%
|
| 1947: 1 | Yankees | Joe DiMaggio | 95%
|
| 1948: 2 | Yankees | Joe DiMaggio | 95%
|
| 1941: 2 | Red Sox | Ted Williams | 95%
|
| 1942: 2 | Red Sox | Ted Williams | 95%
|
| 1946: 1 | Red Sox | Ted Williams | 95%
|
| 1947: 2 | Red Sox | Ted Williams | 95%
|
| 1948: 3 | Red Sox | Ted Williams | 95%
|
| 1949: 1 | Red Sox | Ted Williams | 95%
|
| 1940: 2 | Indians | Bob Feller | 91%
|
| 1941: 3 | Indians | Bob Feller | 91%
|
| 1940: 1 | Tigers | Hank Greenberg | 82%
|
| 1944: 1 | Tigers | Hal Newhouser | 64%
|
| 1945: 1 | Tigers | Hal Newhouser | 64%
|
| 1946: 2 | Tigers | Hal Newhouser | 64%
|
| 1943: 4 | Yankees | Billy Johnson | 55%
|
| 1943: 5 | Senators | Bob Johnson | 55%
|
| 1949: 2 | Yankees | Phil Rizzuto | 55%
|
| 1946: 3 | Red Sox | Bobby Doerr | 50%
|
| 1947: 5 | Tigers | George Kell | 45%
|
| 1943: 2 | White Sox | Luke Appling | 45%
|
| 1942: 1 | Yankees | Joe Gordon | 41%
|
| 1940: 5 | Indians | Lou Boudreau | 41%
|
| 1947: 3 | Indians | Lou Boudreau | 41%
|
| 1948: 1 | Indians | Lou Boudreau | 41%
|
| 1948: 5 | Indians | Bob Lemon | 36%
|
| 1942: 3 | Red Sox | Johnny Pesky | 36%
|
| 1946: 4 | Red Sox | Johnny Pesky | 36%
|
| 1943: 1 | Yankees | Spud Chandler | 36%
|
| 1941: 5 | Yankees | Charlie Keller | 32%
|
| 1944: 2 | Tigers | Dizzy Trout | 27%
|
| 1942: 4 | Browns | Vern Stephens | 27%
|
| 1944: 3 | Browns | Vern Stephens | 27%
|
| 1948: 4 | Red Sox | Vern Stephens | 27%
|
| 1949: 4 | Red Sox | Mel Parnell | 23%
|
| 1943: 3 | Tigers | Rudy York | 23%
|
| 1946: 5 | Senators | Mickey Vernon | 18%
|
| 1944: 4 | Yankees | Snuffy Stirnweiss | 18%
|
| 1945: 3 | Yankees | Snuffy Stirnweiss | 18%
|
| 1940: 4 | Tigers | Bobo Newsom | 14%
|
| 1947: 4 | Yankees | Joe Page | 14%
|
| 1949: 3 | Yankees | Joe Page | 14%
|
| 1949: 5 | Red Sox | Ellis Kinder | 9%
|
| 1945: 4 | Red Sox | Dave Ferriss | 5%
|
| 1944: 5 | Tigers | Dick Wakefield | 5%
|
| 1945: 2 | Tigers | Eddie Mayo | 5%
|
| 1945: 5 | Senators | George Myatt | 5%
|
| 1941: 4 | White Sox | Thornton Lee | 5%
|
| 1942: 5 | Yankees | Tiny Bonham | 5%
|