| Year | Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1952: 3 | Yankees | Mickey Mantle | 100%
|
| 1955: 5 | Yankees | Mickey Mantle | 100%
|
| 1956: 1 | Yankees | Mickey Mantle | 100%
|
| 1957: 1 | Yankees | Mickey Mantle | 100%
|
| 1958: 5 | Yankees | Mickey Mantle | 100%
|
| 1955: 4 | Red Sox | Ted Williams | 100%
|
| 1957: 2 | Red Sox | Ted Williams | 100%
|
| 1950: 3 | Yankees | Yogi Berra | 93%
|
| 1951: 1 | Yankees | Yogi Berra | 93%
|
| 1952: 4 | Yankees | Yogi Berra | 93%
|
| 1953: 2 | Yankees | Yogi Berra | 93%
|
| 1954: 1 | Yankees | Yogi Berra | 93%
|
| 1955: 1 | Yankees | Yogi Berra | 93%
|
| 1956: 2 | Yankees | Yogi Berra | 93%
|
| 1955: 2 | Tigers | Al Kaline | 87%
|
| 1956: 3 | Tigers | Al Kaline | 87%
|
| 1957: 4 | White Sox | Nellie Fox | 80%
|
| 1959: 1 | White Sox | Nellie Fox | 80%
|
| 1950: 1 | Yankees | Phil Rizzuto | 77%
|
| 1951: 5 | Indians | Bob Feller | 70%
|
| 1953: 1 | Indians | Al Rosen | 67%
|
| 1958: 3 | Indians | Rocky Colavito | 67%
|
| 1959: 4 | Indians | Rocky Colavito | 67%
|
| 1954: 2 | Indians | Larry Doby | 63%
|
| 1951: 4 | Indians/White Sox | Minnie Miñoso | 63%
|
| 1953: 4 | White Sox | Minnie Miñoso | 63%
|
| 1954: 4 | White Sox | Minnie Miñoso | 63%
|
| 1952: 1 | Athletics | Bobby Shantz | 57%
|
| 1959: 2 | White Sox | Luis Aparicio | 57%
|
| 1950: 5 | Indians | Bob Lemon | 50%
|
| 1954: 5 | Indians | Bob Lemon | 50%
|
| 1952: 5 | Indians | Early Wynn | 47%
|
| 1959: 3 | White Sox | Early Wynn | 47%
|
| 1958: 1 | Red Sox | Jackie Jensen | 47%
|
| 1950: 4 | Tigers | George Kell | 43%
|
| 1951: 3 | Yankees | Allie Reynolds | 40%
|
| 1952: 2 | Yankees | Allie Reynolds | 40%
|
| 1958: 2 | Yankees | Bob Turley | 40%
|
| 1957: 3 | Senators | Roy Sievers | 40%
|
| 1956: 5 | White Sox | Billy Pierce | 33%
|
| 1958: 4 | Athletics | Bob Cerv | 33%
|
| 1954: 3 | Indians | Bobby Ávila | 30%
|
| 1957: 5 | Yankees | Gil McDougald | 30%
|
| 1953: 3 | Senators | Mickey Vernon | 27%
|
| 1950: 2 | Red Sox | Billy Goodman | 23%
|
| 1956: 4 | Tigers | Harvey Kuenn | 20%
|
| 1955: 3 | Indians | Al Smith | 17%
|
| 1951: 2 | Browns | Ned Garver | 17%
|
| 1959: 5 | Indians | Tito Francona | 17%
|
| 1953: 5 | Browns/White Sox | Virgil Trucks | 17%
|