| Year | Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2003: 1 | Blue Jays | Roy Halladay | 100%
|
| 2006: 3 | Blue Jays | Roy Halladay | 100%
|
| 2007: 5 | Blue Jays | Roy Halladay | 100%
|
| 2008: 2 | Blue Jays | Roy Halladay | 100%
|
| 2009: 5 | Blue Jays | Roy Halladay | 100%
|
| 2000: 1 | Red Sox | Pedro Martínez | 95%
|
| 2002: 2 | Red Sox | Pedro Martínez | 95%
|
| 2003: 3 | Red Sox | Pedro Martínez | 95%
|
| 2004: 4 | Red Sox | Pedro Martínez | 95%
|
| 2001: 1 | Yankees | Roger Clemens | 91%
|
| 2007: 1 | Indians | CC Sabathia | 86%
|
| 2009: 4 | Yankees | CC Sabathia | 86%
|
| 2009: 2 | Mariners | Félix Hernández | 86%
|
| 2000: 4 | Yankees | Andy Pettitte | 82%
|
| 2005: 1 | Angels | Bartolo Colón | 82%
|
| 2004: 1 | Twins | Johan Santana | 82%
|
| 2005: 3 | Twins | Johan Santana | 82%
|
| 2006: 1 | Twins | Johan Santana | 82%
|
| 2007: 5 | Twins | Johan Santana | 82%
|
| 2007: 5 | Tigers | Justin Verlander | 82%
|
| 2009: 3 | Tigers | Justin Verlander | 82%
|
| 2007: 4 | Indians | Roberto Hernández | 82%
|
| 2001: 5 | Yankees | Mike Mussina | 77%
|
| 2002: 1 | Mariners | Barry Zito | 73%
|
| 2009: 1 | Royals | Zack Greinke | 73%
|
| 2005: 4 | Indians | Cliff Lee | 68%
|
| 2008: 1 | Indians | Cliff Lee | 68%
|
| 2004: 2 | Red Sox | Curt Schilling | 68%
|
| 2004: 3 | Yankees | Mariano Rivera | 68%
|
| 2005: 2 | Yankees | Mariano Rivera | 68%
|
| 2008: 5 | Yankees | Mariano Rivera | 68%
|
| 2000: 2 | Athletics | Tim Hudson | 64%
|
| 2003: 4 | Athletics | Tim Hudson | 64%
|
| 2001: 2 | Athletics | Mark Mulder | 59%
|
| 2005: 5 | White Sox | Mark Buehrle | 50%
|
| 2000: 3 | Blue Jays | David Wells | 45%
|
| 2002: 3 | Red Sox | Derek Lowe | 45%
|
| 2004: 4 | Angels | Francisco Rodríguez | 45%
|
| 2006: 4 | Angels | Francisco Rodríguez | 45%
|
| 2008: 3 | Angels | Francisco Rodríguez | 45%
|
| 2001: 4 | Mariners | Jamie Moyer | 45%
|
| 2003: 5 | Mariners | Jamie Moyer | 45%
|
| 2007: 3 | Angels | John Lackey | 45%
|
| 2007: 2 | Red Sox | Josh Beckett | 45%
|
| 2004: 4 | Twins | Joe Nathan | 41%
|
| 2006: 5 | Twins | Joe Nathan | 41%
|
| 2000: 5 | Tigers | Todd Jones | 41%
|
| 2007: 5 | Orioles | Érik Bédard | 18%
|
| 2003: 2 | White Sox | Esteban Loaiza | 18%
|
| 2008: 4 | Red Sox | Daisuke Matsuzaka | 14%
|
| 2001: 3 | Mariners | Freddy García | 14%
|
| 2002: 4 | Angels | Jarrod Washburn | 14%
|
| 2006: 5 | Tigers | Kenny Rogers | 14%
|
| 2006: 2 | Yankees | Chien-Ming Wang | 9%
|