| Year | Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2020: 4 | Yankees | Gerrit Cole | 97%
|
| 2021: 2 | Yankees | Gerrit Cole | 97%
|
| 2023: 1 | Yankees | Gerrit Cole | 97%
|
| 2020: 1 | Indians | Shane Bieber | 94%
|
| 2024: 1 | Tigers | Tarik Skubal | 94%
|
| 2025: 1 | Tigers | Tarik Skubal | 94%
|
| 2025: 2 | Red Sox | Garrett Crochet | 88%
|
| 2025: 5 | Mariners | Bryan Woo | 82%
|
| 2022: 1 | Astros | Justin Verlander | 82%
|
| 2025: 3 | Astros | Hunter Brown | 79%
|
| 2025: 4 | Yankees | Max Fried | 79%
|
| 2022: 5 | Astros | Framber Valdez | 73%
|
| 2023: 3 | Blue Jays | Kevin Gausman | 73%
|
| 2024: 4 | Royals | Cole Ragans | 70%
|
| 2024: 5 | Orioles | Corbin Burnes | 67%
|
| 2022: 2 | White Sox | Dylan Cease | 67%
|
| 2023: 5 | Mariners | Luis Castillo | 58%
|
| 2021: 1 | Blue Jays | Robbie Ray | 58%
|
| 2024: 2 | Royals | Seth Lugo | 58%
|
| 2022: 4 | Angels | Shohei Ohtani | 55%
|
| 2023: 2 | Twins | Sonny Gray | 48%
|
| 2024: 3 | Guardians | Emmanuel Clase | 45%
|
| 2022: 3 | Blue Jays | Alek Manoah | 42%
|
| 2021: 5 | White Sox | Carlos Rodón | 42%
|
| 2023: 4 | Orioles | Kyle Bradish | 36%
|
| 2020: 3 | Blue Jays | Hyun Jin Ryu | 33%
|
| 2021: 3 | White Sox | Lance Lynn | 33%
|
| 2021: 4 | Red Sox | Nathan Eovaldi | 33%
|
| 2020: 2 | Twins | Kenta Maeda | 27%
|
| 2020: 5 | White Sox | Dallas Keuchel | 24%
|