| Year | Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1960: 1 | Yankees | Roger Maris | 98%
|
| 1961: 1 | Yankees | Roger Maris | 98%
|
| 1960: 3 | Orioles | Brooks Robinson | 95%
|
| 1964: 1 | Orioles | Brooks Robinson | 95%
|
| 1965: 3 | Orioles | Brooks Robinson | 95%
|
| 1966: 2 | Orioles | Brooks Robinson | 95%
|
| 1967: 1 | Red Sox | Carl Yastrzemski | 95%
|
| 1966: 1 | Orioles | Frank Robinson | 95%
|
| 1969: 3 | Orioles | Frank Robinson | 95%
|
| 1962: 3 | Twins | Harmon Killebrew | 95%
|
| 1963: 4 | Twins | Harmon Killebrew | 95%
|
| 1966: 4 | Twins | Harmon Killebrew | 95%
|
| 1967: 2 | Twins | Harmon Killebrew | 95%
|
| 1969: 1 | Twins | Harmon Killebrew | 95%
|
| 1960: 2 | Yankees | Mickey Mantle | 95%
|
| 1961: 2 | Yankees | Mickey Mantle | 95%
|
| 1962: 1 | Yankees | Mickey Mantle | 95%
|
| 1964: 2 | Yankees | Mickey Mantle | 95%
|
| 1963: 2 | Tigers | Al Kaline | 89%
|
| 1967: 5 | Tigers | Al Kaline | 89%
|
| 1969: 5 | Athletics | Reggie Jackson | 86%
|
| 1968: 1 | Tigers | Denny McLain | 80%
|
| 1963: 1 | Yankees | Elston Howard | 77%
|
| 1964: 3 | Yankees | Elston Howard | 77%
|
| 1969: 4 | Frank Howard | 77%
| |
| 1966: 3 | Orioles | Boog Powell | 75%
|
| 1969: 2 | Orioles | Boog Powell | 75%
|
| 1964: 4 | Twins | Tony Oliva | 73%
|
| 1965: 2 | Twins | Tony Oliva | 73%
|
| 1961: 5 | Yankees | Whitey Ford | 73%
|
| 1963: 3 | Yankees | Whitey Ford | 73%
|
| 1961: 4 | Tigers | Norm Cash | 70%
|
| 1965: 1 | Twins | Zoilo Versalles | 61%
|
| 1965: 5 | Indians | Rocky Colavito | 55%
|
| 1962: 2 | Yankees | Bobby Richardson | 50%
|
| 1964: 5 | Angels | Dean Chance | 50%
|
| 1966: 5 | Twins | Jim Kaat | 48%
|
| 1968: 4 | Tigers | Willie Horton | 43%
|
| 1968: 5 | Orioles | Dave McNally | 41%
|
| 1961: 3 | Orioles | Jim Gentile | 39%
|
| 1960: 4 | White Sox | Minnie Miñoso | 39%
|
| 1967: 3 | Tigers | Bill Freehan | 34%
|
| 1968: 2 | Tigers | Bill Freehan | 34%
|
| 1968: 5 | Indians | Luis Tiant | 34%
|
| 1968: 3 | Red Sox | Ken Harrelson | 23%
|
| 1962: 4 | Angels | Leon Wagner | 23%
|
| 1967: 4 | White Sox | Joe Horlen | 20%
|
| 1963: 5 | Red Sox | Dick Radatz | 18%
|
| 1960: 5 | Orioles | Ron Hansen | 18%
|
| 1962: 5 | Indians | Dick Donovan | 9%
|
| 1965: 4 | White Sox | Eddie Fisher | 7%
|