| Year | Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2000: 3 | Mariners | Alex Rodriguez | 98%
|
| 2002: 2 | Rangers | Alex Rodriguez | 98%
|
| 2003: 1 | Rangers | Alex Rodriguez | 98%
|
| 2005: 1 | Yankees | Alex Rodriguez | 98%
|
| 2007: 1 | Yankees | Alex Rodriguez | 98%
|
| 2003: 5 | Red Sox | David Ortiz | 95%
|
| 2004: 4 | Red Sox | David Ortiz | 95%
|
| 2005: 2 | Red Sox | David Ortiz | 95%
|
| 2006: 3 | Red Sox | David Ortiz | 95%
|
| 2007: 4 | Red Sox | David Ortiz | 95%
|
| 2006: 2 | Yankees | Derek Jeter | 92%
|
| 2009: 3 | Yankees | Derek Jeter | 92%
|
| 2000: 2 | White Sox | Frank Thomas | 92%
|
| 2006: 4 | Athletics | Frank Thomas | 92%
|
| 2001: 1 | Mariners | Ichiro Suzuki | 92%
|
| 2004: 3 | Red Sox | Manny Ramirez | 92%
|
| 2005: 4 | Red Sox | Manny Ramirez | 92%
|
| 2008: 4 | Twins | Joe Mauer | 91%
|
| 2009: 1 | Twins | Joe Mauer | 91%
|
| 2000: 5 | Red Sox | Pedro Martínez | 89%
|
| 2008: 1 | Red Sox | Dustin Pedroia | 88%
|
| 2000: 1 | Athletics | Jason Giambi | 86%
|
| 2001: 2 | Athletics | Jason Giambi | 86%
|
| 2002: 5 | Yankees | Jason Giambi | 86%
|
| 2009: 4 | Tigers | Miguel Cabrera | 85%
|
| 2006: 1 | Twins | Justin Morneau | 80%
|
| 2008: 2 | Twins | Justin Morneau | 80%
|
| 2004: 1 | Angels | Vladimir Guerrero | 80%
|
| 2005: 3 | Angels | Vladimir Guerrero | 80%
|
| 2007: 3 | Angels | Vladimir Guerrero | 80%
|
| 2002: 1 | Athletics | Miguel Tejada | 75%
|
| 2004: 5 | Orioles | Miguel Tejada | 75%
|
| 2003: 3 | Yankees | Jorge Posada | 74%
|
| 2000: 4 | Blue Jays | Carlos Delgado | 72%
|
| 2003: 2 | Blue Jays | Carlos Delgado | 72%
|
| 2009: 2 | Yankees | Mark Teixeira | 68%
|
| 2007: 2 | Tigers | Magglio Ordóñez | 60%
|
| 2002: 4 | Angels | Garret Anderson | 57%
|
| 2001: 4 | Indians | Roberto Alomar | 55%
|
| 2001: 3 | Mariners | Bret Boone | 54%
|
| 2005: 5 | Indians | Travis Hafner | 49%
|
| 2006: 5 | White Sox | Jermaine Dye | 43%
|
| 2002: 3 | Yankees | Alfonso Soriano | 42%
|
| 2008: 3 | Red Sox | Kevin Youkilis | 40%
|
| 2004: 2 | Yankees | Gary Sheffield | 38%
|
| 2007: 5 | Red Sox | Mike Lowell | 38%
|
| 2001: 5 | Indians | Juan González | 34%
|
| 2008: 5 | White Sox | Carlos Quentin | 17%
|
| 2009: 5 | Angels | Kendrys Morales | 14%
|
| 2003: 4 | Blue Jays/Twins | Shannon Stewart | 14%
|