| Year | Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2000: 3 | Braves | Greg Maddux | 100%
|
| 2000: 1 | Diamondbacks | Randy Johnson | 100%
|
| 2001: 1 | Diamondbacks | Randy Johnson | 100%
|
| 2002: 1 | Diamondbacks | Randy Johnson | 100%
|
| 2004: 2 | Diamondbacks | Randy Johnson | 100%
|
| 2001: 2 | Diamondbacks | Curt Schilling | 86%
|
| 2002: 2 | Diamondbacks | Curt Schilling | 86%
|
| 2002: 3 | Braves | John Smoltz | 86%
|
| 2008: 1 | Giants | Tim Lincecum | 86%
|
| 2009: 1 | Giants | Tim Lincecum | 86%
|
| 2000: 2 | Braves | Tom Glavine | 86%
|
| 2005: 1 | Cardinals | Chris Carpenter | 79%
|
| 2006: 3 | Cardinals | Chris Carpenter | 79%
|
| 2009: 2 | Cardinals | Chris Carpenter | 79%
|
| 2004: 1 | Astros | Roger Clemens | 79%
|
| 2005: 3 | Astros | Roger Clemens | 79%
|
| 2009: 3 | Cardinals | Adam Wainwright | 64%
|
| 2006: 1 | Diamondbacks | Brandon Webb | 64%
|
| 2007: 2 | Diamondbacks | Brandon Webb | 64%
|
| 2008: 2 | Diamondbacks | Brandon Webb | 64%
|
| 2008: 5 | Brewers | CC Sabathia | 64%
|
| 2005: 2 | Marlins | Dontrelle Willis | 64%
|
| 2002: 4 | Dodgers | Éric Gagné | 64%
|
| 2003: 1 | Dodgers | Éric Gagné | 64%
|
| 2007: 1 | Padres | Jake Peavy | 64%
|
| 2003: 3 | Cubs | Mark Prior | 64%
|
| 2001: 5 | Astros | Roy Oswalt | 64%
|
| 2002: 4 | Astros | Roy Oswalt | 64%
|
| 2004: 3 | Astros | Roy Oswalt | 64%
|
| 2005: 4 | Astros | Roy Oswalt | 64%
|
| 2006: 4 | Astros | Roy Oswalt | 64%
|
| 2004: 5 | Cubs | Carlos Zambrano | 57%
|
| 2006: 5 | Cubs | Carlos Zambrano | 57%
|
| 2007: 5 | Cubs | Carlos Zambrano | 57%
|
| 2006: 2 | Padres | Trevor Hoffman | 50%
|
| 2005: 5 | Astros | Andy Pettitte | 43%
|
| 2008: 3 | Mets | Johan Santana | 43%
|
| 2001: 3 | Cardinals | Matt Morris | 43%
|
| 2003: 2 | Giants | Jason Schmidt | 36%
|
| 2003: 4 | Braves | Russ Ortiz | 36%
|
| 2009: 4 | Braves | Javier Vázquez | 29%
|
| 2007: 4 | Reds | Aaron Harang | 21%
|
| 2007: 3 | Dodgers | Brad Penny | 21%
|
| 2009: 5 | Diamondbacks | Dan Haren | 21%
|
| 2000: 5 | Cardinals | Darryl Kile | 21%
|
| 2001: 4 | Cubs | Jon Lieber | 21%
|
| 2000: 4 | Giants | Robb Nen | 21%
|
| 2008: 4 | Phillies | Brad Lidge | 14%
|
| 2004: 4 | Giants | Chad Cordero | 7%
|
| 2005: 5 | Nationals | Chad Cordero | 7%
|