| Year | Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1911: 2 | Giants | Christy Mathewson | 100%
|
| 1913: 4 | Giants | Christy Mathewson | 100%
|
| 1913: 2 | Phillies | Gavy Cravath | 100%
|
| 1911: 3 | Phillies | Grover Alexander | 100%
|
| 1911: 3 | Pirates | Honus Wagner | 100%
|
| 1912: 2 | Pirates | Honus Wagner | 100%
|
| 1912: 4 | Cubs | Joe Tinker | 100%
|
| 1914: 1 | Braves | Johnny Evers | 100%
|
| 1913: 3 | Braves | Rabbit Maranville | 100%
|
| 1914: 2 | Braves | Rabbit Maranville | 100%
|
| 1914: 3 | Braves | Bill James | 50%
|
| 1911: 1 | Cubs | Frank Schulte | 50%
|
| 1914: 3 | Giants | George Burns | 50%
|
| 1912: 3 | Giants | Jack Meyers | 50%
|
| 1913: 5 | Giants | Jack Meyers | 50%
|
| 1913: 1 | Dodgers | Jake Daubert | 50%
|
| 1911: 3 | Giants | Larry Doyle | 50%
|
| 1912: 1 | Giants | Larry Doyle | 50%
|
| 1912: 5 | Reds | Bob Bescher | 0%
|
| 1914: 5 | Cardinals | Dots Miller | 0%
|