| Year | Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1924: 2 | Cardinals | Rogers Hornsby | 94%
|
| 1925: 1 | Cardinals | Rogers Hornsby | 94%
|
| 1927: 3 | Giants | Rogers Hornsby | 94%
|
| 1929: 1 | Cubs | Rogers Hornsby | 94%
|
| 1929: 5 | Pirates | Lloyd Waner | 88%
|
| 1927: 1 | Pirates | Paul Waner | 88%
|
| 1929: 3 | Giants | Bill Terry | 69%
|
| 1924: 1 | Robins | Dazzy Vance | 63%
|
| 1925: 5 | Robins | Dazzy Vance | 63%
|
| 1924: 3 | Giants | Frankie Frisch | 63%
|
| 1927: 2 | Cardinals | Frankie Frisch | 63%
|
| 1926: 5 | Cubs | Hack Wilson | 56%
|
| 1925: 2 | Pirates | Kiki Cuyler | 44%
|
| 1924: 3 | Robins | Zack Wheat | 44%
|
| 1928: 1 | Cardinals | Jim Bottomley | 38%
|
| 1929: 2 | Phillies | Lefty O'Doul | 38%
|
| 1927: 5 | Giants | Travis Jackson | 38%
|
| 1926: 1 | Cardinals | Bob O'Farrell | 31%
|
| 1927: 4 | Cubs | Charlie Root | 31%
|
| 1928: 2 | Giants | Freddie Lindstrom | 31%
|
| 1925: 3 | Giants | George Kelly | 31%
|
| 1924: 5 | Giants | Ross Youngs | 25%
|
| 1928: 3 | Pirates | Burleigh Grimes | 19%
|
| 1929: 4 | Pirates | Burleigh Grimes | 19%
|
| 1926: 3 | Pirates | Ray Kremer | 13%
|
| 1926: 4 | Cardinals | Tommy Thevenow | 13%
|
| 1925: 4 | Pirates | Glenn Wright | 6%
|
| 1926: 2 | Reds | Hughie Critz | 6%
|
| 1928: 4 | Reds | Hughie Critz | 6%
|
| 1928: 4 | Giants | Larry Benton | 6%
|