| Year | Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1934: 1 | Cardinals | Dizzy Dean | 100%
|
| 1935: 2 | Cardinals | Dizzy Dean | 100%
|
| 1936: 2 | Cardinals | Dizzy Dean | 100%
|
| 1933: 1 | Giants | Carl Hubbell | 84%
|
| 1936: 1 | Giants | Carl Hubbell | 84%
|
| 1937: 3 | Giants | Carl Hubbell | 84%
|
| 1934: 5 | Giants | Mel Ott | 84%
|
| 1938: 4 | Giants | Mel Ott | 84%
|
| 1931: 2 | Phillies | Chuck Klein | 79%
|
| 1932: 1 | Phillies | Chuck Klein | 79%
|
| 1933: 2 | Phillies | Chuck Klein | 79%
|
| 1931: 1 | Cardinals | Frankie Frisch | 79%
|
| 1935: 3 | Pirates | Arky Vaughan | 74%
|
| 1938: 3 | Pirates | Arky Vaughan | 74%
|
| 1931: 3 | Giants | Bill Terry | 74%
|
| 1933: 4 | Giants | Bill Terry | 74%
|
| 1935: 5 | Cardinals | Joe Medwick | 74%
|
| 1936: 4 | Cardinals | Joe Medwick | 74%
|
| 1937: 1 | Cardinals | Joe Medwick | 74%
|
| 1932: 4 | Pirates | Paul Waner | 68%
|
| 1934: 2 | Pirates | Paul Waner | 68%
|
| 1936: 5 | Pirates | Paul Waner | 68%
|
| 1935: 4 | Cubs | Billy Herman | 63%
|
| 1936: 3 | Cubs | Billy Herman | 63%
|
| 1938: 1 | Reds | Ernie Lombardi | 58%
|
| 1935: 1 | Cubs | Gabby Hartnett | 58%
|
| 1937: 2 | Cubs | Gabby Hartnett | 58%
|
| 1939: 2 | Cardinals | Johnny Mize | 53%
|
| 1939: 1 | Reds | Bucky Walters | 42%
|
| 1933: 3 | Braves | Wally Berger | 42%
|
| 1938: 5 | Reds | Frank McCormick | 37%
|
| 1939: 4 | Reds | Frank McCormick | 37%
|
| 1934: 4 | Giants | Travis Jackson | 37%
|
| 1932: 3 | Dodgers | Lefty O'Doul | 32%
|
| 1933: 5 | Cardinals | Pepper Martin | 32%
|
| 1939: 3 | Reds | Paul Derringer | 26%
|
| 1931: 5 | Cardinals | Chick Hafey | 21%
|
| 1934: 3 | Giants | Jo-Jo Moore | 21%
|
| 1932: 2 | Cubs | Lon Warneke | 21%
|
| 1932: 5 | Cubs | Riggs Stephenson | 21%
|
| 1937: 4 | Bees | Jim Turner | 16%
|
| 1931: 4 | Cubs | Woody English | 16%
|
| 1938: 2 | Cubs | Bill Lee | 5%
|
| 1939: 5 | Cardinals | Curt Davis | 5%
|
| 1937: 5 | Bees | Lou Fette | 5%
|