| Year | Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1953: 3 | Dodgers | Duke Snider | 100%
|
| 1954: 4 | Dodgers | Duke Snider | 100%
|
| 1955: 2 | Dodgers | Duke Snider | 100%
|
| 1953: 2 | Braves | Eddie Mathews | 100%
|
| 1959: 2 | Braves | Eddie Mathews | 100%
|
| 1955: 3 | Cubs | Ernie Banks | 100%
|
| 1958: 1 | Cubs | Ernie Banks | 100%
|
| 1959: 1 | Cubs | Ernie Banks | 100%
|
| 1956: 3 | Braves | Henry Aaron | 100%
|
| 1957: 1 | Braves | Henry Aaron | 100%
|
| 1958: 3 | Braves | Henry Aaron | 100%
|
| 1959: 3 | Braves | Henry Aaron | 100%
|
| 1950: 2 | Cardinals | Stan Musial | 100%
|
| 1951: 2 | Cardinals | Stan Musial | 100%
|
| 1952: 5 | Cardinals | Stan Musial | 100%
|
| 1957: 2 | Cardinals | Stan Musial | 100%
|
| 1954: 1 | Giants | Willie Mays | 100%
|
| 1955: 4 | Giants | Willie Mays | 100%
|
| 1957: 4 | Giants | Willie Mays | 100%
|
| 1958: 2 | Giants | Willie Mays | 100%
|
| 1950: 5 | Pirates | Ralph Kiner | 90%
|
| 1951: 1 | Dodgers | Roy Campanella | 90%
|
| 1953: 1 | Dodgers | Roy Campanella | 90%
|
| 1955: 1 | Dodgers | Roy Campanella | 90%
|
| 1956: 1 | Dodgers | Don Newcombe | 80%
|
| 1953: 5 | Braves | Warren Spahn | 80%
|
| 1956: 4 | Braves | Warren Spahn | 80%
|
| 1957: 5 | Braves | Warren Spahn | 80%
|
| 1958: 5 | Braves | Warren Spahn | 80%
|
| 1950: 1 | Phillies | Jim Konstanty | 70%
|
| 1956: 5 | Dodgers | Jim Gilliam | 60%
|
| 1951: 3 | Giants | Monte Irvin | 60%
|
| 1952: 2 | Phillies | Robin Roberts | 60%
|
| 1955: 5 | Phillies | Robin Roberts | 60%
|
| 1952: 1 | Cubs | Hank Sauer | 50%
|
| 1953: 4 | Cardinals | Red Schoendienst | 50%
|
| 1957: 3 | Giants/Braves | Red Schoendienst | 50%
|
| 1954: 2 | Redlegs | Ted Kluszewski | 50%
|
| 1954: 5 | Giants | Al Dark | 40%
|
| 1950: 4 | Phillies | Del Ennis | 40%
|
| 1958: 4 | Pirates | Frank Thomas | 40%
|
| 1951: 4 | Giants | Sal Maglie | 40%
|
| 1956: 2 | Dodgers | Sal Maglie | 40%
|
| 1950: 3 | Giants | Eddie Stanky | 30%
|
| 1952: 4 | Giants | Hoyt Wilhelm | 30%
|
| 1951: 5 | Dodgers | Preacher Roe | 30%
|
| 1959: 4 | Dodgers | Wally Moon | 30%
|
| 1952: 3 | Dodgers | Joe Black | 20%
|
| 1954: 3 | Giants | Johnny Antonelli | 20%
|
| 1959: 5 | Giants | Sam Jones | 20%
|