| Year | Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2015: 1 | Nationals | Bryce Harper | 95%
|
| 2010: 1 | Reds | Joey Votto | 95%
|
| 2015: 3 | Reds | Joey Votto | 95%
|
| 2017: 2 | Reds | Joey Votto | 95%
|
| 2012: 3 | Pirates | Andrew McCutchen | 93%
|
| 2013: 1 | Pirates | Andrew McCutchen | 93%
|
| 2014: 3 | Pirates | Andrew McCutchen | 93%
|
| 2015: 5 | Pirates | Andrew McCutchen | 93%
|
| 2014: 2 | Marlins | Giancarlo Stanton | 93%
|
| 2017: 1 | Marlins | Giancarlo Stanton | 93%
|
| 2016: 1 | Cubs | Kris Bryant | 92%
|
| 2018: 1 | Brewers | Christian Yelich | 91%
|
| 2019: 2 | Brewers | Christian Yelich | 91%
|
| 2014: 1 | Dodgers | Clayton Kershaw | 91%
|
| 2010: 2 | Cardinals | Albert Pujols | 90%
|
| 2011: 5 | Cardinals | Albert Pujols | 90%
|
| 2011: 1 | Brewers | Ryan Braun | 90%
|
| 2012: 2 | Brewers | Ryan Braun | 90%
|
| 2013: 2 | Diamondbacks | Paul Goldschmidt | 89%
|
| 2015: 2 | Diamondbacks | Paul Goldschmidt | 89%
|
| 2017: 3 | Diamondbacks | Paul Goldschmidt | 89%
|
| 2019: 5 | Braves | Ronald Acuña Jr. | 89%
|
| 2015: 4 | Cubs | Anthony Rizzo | 87%
|
| 2016: 4 | Cubs | Anthony Rizzo | 87%
|
| 2016: 5 | Rockies | Nolan Arenado | 87%
|
| 2017: 4 | Rockies | Nolan Arenado | 87%
|
| 2018: 3 | Rockies | Nolan Arenado | 87%
|
| 2012: 1 | Giants | Buster Posey | 85%
|
| 2013: 5 | Braves | Freddie Freeman | 81%
|
| 2018: 4 | Braves | Freddie Freeman | 81%
|
| 2019: 1 | Dodgers | Cody Bellinger | 80%
|
| 2012: 4 | Cardinals | Yadier Molina | 78%
|
| 2013: 3 | Cardinals | Yadier Molina | 78%
|
| 2018: 2 | Cubs | Javier Báez | 76%
|
| 2017: 5 | Rockies | Charlie Blackmon | 75%
|
| 2010: 4 | Padres | Adrián González | 73%
|
| 2011: 2 | Dodgers | Matt Kemp | 72%
|
| 2010: 3 | Rockies | Carlos González | 70%
|
| 2019: 4 | Diamondbacks | Ketel Marte | 70%
|
| 2010: 5 | Rockies | Troy Tulowitzki | 68%
|
| 2014: 5 | Nationals | Anthony Rendon | 66%
|
| 2019: 3 | Nationals | Anthony Rendon | 66%
|
| 2011: 3 | Brewers | Prince Fielder | 64%
|
| 2018: 5 | Mets | Jacob deGrom | 63%
|
| 2013: 4 | Cardinals | Matt Carpenter | 53%
|
| 2016: 2 | Nationals | Daniel Murphy | 45%
|
| 2016: 3 | Dodgers | Corey Seager | 41%
|
| 2011: 4 | Diamondbacks | Justin Upton | 31%
|
| 2014: 4 | Brewers | Jonathan Lucroy | 26%
|
| 2012: 5 | Padres | Chase Headley | 25%
|