| Season | Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1966 | Packers | Bart Starr | 100%
|
| 1962 | Packers | Bart Starr | 100%
|
| 1961 | Packers | Bart Starr | 100%
|
| 1960 | Packers | Bart Starr | 100%
|
| 1967 | Colts | Johnny Unitas | 100%
|
| 1966 | Colts | Johnny Unitas | 100%
|
| 1964 | Colts | Johnny Unitas | 100%
|
| 1963 | Colts | Johnny Unitas | 100%
|
| 1962 | Colts | Johnny Unitas | 100%
|
| 1961 | Colts | Johnny Unitas | 100%
|
| 1960 | Colts | Johnny Unitas | 100%
|
| 1969 | Giants | Fran Tarkenton | 88%
|
| 1968 | Giants | Fran Tarkenton | 88%
|
| 1967 | Giants | Fran Tarkenton | 88%
|
| 1965 | Vikings | Fran Tarkenton | 88%
|
| 1964 | Vikings | Fran Tarkenton | 88%
|
| 1960 | Eagles | Norm Van Brocklin | 82%
|
| 1969 | Redskins | Sonny Jurgensen | 82%
|
| 1967 | Redskins | Sonny Jurgensen | 82%
|
| 1966 | Redskins | Sonny Jurgensen | 82%
|
| 1964 | Redskins | Sonny Jurgensen | 82%
|
| 1961 | Eagles | Sonny Jurgensen | 82%
|
| 1968 | Colts | Earl Morrall | 76%
|
| 1963 | Giants | Y. A. Tittle | 76%
|
| 1962 | Giants | Y. A. Tittle | 76%
|
| 1961 | Giants | Y. A. Tittle | 76%
|
| 1965 | 49ers | John Brodie | 71%
|
| 1969 | Rams | Roman Gabriel | 71%
|
| 1968 | Rams | Roman Gabriel | 71%
|
| 1967 | Rams | Roman Gabriel | 71%
|
| 1968 | Cowboys | Don Meredith | 65%
|
| 1967 | Cowboys | Don Meredith | 65%
|
| 1966 | Cowboys | Don Meredith | 65%
|
| 1969 | Vikings | Joe Kapp | 65%
|
| 1963 | Cardinals | Charley Johnson | 41%
|
| 1963 | Bears | Billy Wade | 29%
|
| 1962 | Cowboys | Eddie LeBaron | 29%
|
| 1961 | Browns | Milt Plum | 29%
|
| 1960 | Browns | Milt Plum | 29%
|
| 1965 | Eagles | Norm Snead | 29%
|
| 1963 | Redskins | Norm Snead | 29%
|
| 1962 | Redskins | Norm Snead | 29%
|
| 1969 | Browns | Bill Nelsen | 24%
|
| 1966 | Browns | Frank Ryan | 24%
|
| 1965 | Browns | Frank Ryan | 24%
|
| 1964 | Browns | Frank Ryan | 24%
|
| 1969 | Falcons | Bob Berry | 18%
|