| Year | Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1964: 4 | 1965: 6 | 1966: 4 | 1968: 8 | Vikings | Bill Brown | 91%
|
| 1960: 1 | 1961: 1 | 1962: 4 | +3 others | Browns | Jim Brown | 91%
|
| 1969: 4 | Redskins | Larry Brown | 91%
|
| 1963: 3 | 1965: 3 | Eagles | Timmy Brown | 91%
|
| 1965: 2 | 1966: 1 | 1967: 3 | +2 others | Bears | Gale Sayers | 73%
|
| 1964: 6 | Redskins | Charley Taylor | 64%
|
| 1960: 2 | 1961: 2 | 1962: 1 | +4 others | Packers | Jim Taylor | 64%
|
| 1960: 7 | Packers | Paul Hornung | 55%
|
| 1960: 5 | 1961: 5 | 1962: 6 | 49ers | J.D. Smith | 45%
|
| 1960: 8 | 1961: 7 | 1962: 2 | +2 others | Steelers | John Henry Johnson | 45%
|
| 1966: 2 | 1967: 1 | 1968: 1 | 1969: 7 | Browns | Leroy Kelly | 45%
|
| 1969: 2 | Cowboys | Calvin Hill | 36%
|
| 1961: 6 | 1962: 5 | 1963: 10 | +5 others | Cowboys | Don Perkins | 36%
|
| 1966: 7 | 1967: 9 | Browns | Ernie Green | 36%
|
| 1961: 10 | 1964: 9 | Colts | Lenny Moore | 36%
|
| 1963: 8 | Packers | Tom Moore | 36%
|
| 1968: 9 | Packers | Donny Anderson | 27%
|
| 1961: 9 | Colts | Joe Perry | 27%
|
| 1965: 4 | 1966: 5 | 1968: 2 | 49ers | Ken Willard | 27%
|
| 1968: 10 | 1969: 3 | Colts | Tom Matte | 27%
|
| 1969: 6 | Cowboys | Walt Garrison | 27%
|
| 1961: 3 | 1962: 9 | Giants | Alex Webster | 18%
|
| 1962: 3 | 1966: 3 | Rams | Dick Bass | 18%
|
| 1967: 10 | Giants | Ernie Koy | 18%
|
| 1965: 8 | Giants | Tucker Frederickson | 18%
|
| 1969: 8 | Saints | Andy Livingston | 9%
|
| 1969: 9 | Falcons | Cannonball Butler | 9%
|
| 1967: 2 | 1969: 10 | Vikings | Dave Osborn | 9%
|
| 1963: 7 | 1968: 4 | Steelers | Dick Hoak | 9%
|
| 1960: 3 | 1962: 8 | 1964: 10 | Cardinals | John David Crow | 9%
|
| 1967: 4 | Cardinals | Johnny Roland | 9%
|
| 1966: 9 | 1967: 8 | Falcons | Junior Coffey | 9%
|
| 1967: 7 | Rams | Les Josephson | 9%
|
| 1967: 5 | Lions | Mel Farr | 9%
|
| 1960: 4 | 1961: 4 | Lions | Nick Pietrosante | 9%
|
| 1960: 10 | Bears | Rick Casares | 9%
|
| 1968: 3 | 1969: 5 | Eagles | Tom Woodeshick | 9%
|
| 1968: 7 | Cardinals | Willis Crenshaw | 9%
|
| 1962: 7 | Cowboys | Amos Marsh | 0%
|
| 1963: 9 | 1965: 9 | Cardinals | Bill Triplett | 0%
|
| 1966: 6 | Cowboys | Dan Reeves | 0%
|
| 1964: 7 | Eagles | Earl Gros | 0%
|
| 1963: 6 | Cardinals | Joe Childress | 0%
|
| 1960: 9 | Giants | Mel Triplett | 0%
|
| 1962: 10 | 1963: 5 | 1964: 8 | 1965: 10 | Vikings | Tommy Mason | 0%
|
| 1960: 6 | Steelers | Tom Tracy | 0%
|
| 1961: 8 | Bears | Willie Galimore | 0%
|