| Season | Club (Player Nationality) | Goal scored (Appearances) | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17-18 | SS Lazio (Italian) | 8 (9) | Ciro Immobile | 100%
|
| 19-20 | Sporting Clube de Portugal & Manchester United FC (Portuguese) | 8 (10) | Bruno Fernandes | 94%
|
| Manchester United FC (Portuguese) | 7 (14) | Bruno Fernandes | 94%
| |
| 10-11 | FC Porto (Colombian) | 17 (14) | Radamel Falcao | 94%
|
| 11-12 | Club Atlético de Madrid (Colombian) | 12 (15) | Radamel Falcao | 94%
|
| 18-19 | Chelsea FC (French) | 11 (14) | Olivier Giroud | 88%
|
| 23-24 | Olympique Marseille (Gabonese) | 10 (13) | Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang | 88%
|
| 22-23 | Manchester United FC (English) | 6 (9) | Marcus Rashford | 81%
|
| Everton FC (Belgian) | 8 (9) | Romelu Lukaku | 75%
| |
| 16-17 | AS Roma (Bosnian) | 8 (8) | Edin Dzeko | 69%
|
| 15-16 | Athletic Club (Spanish) | 10 (11) | Aritz Aduriz | 63%
|
| Athletic Club (Spanish) | 8 (10) | Aritz Aduriz | 63%
| |
| 24-25 | Olympiacos Piraeus (Moroccan) | 7 (8) | Ayoub El Kaabi | 44%
|
| Villareal CF (Spanish) | 7 (12) | Gerard Moreno | 44%
| |
| 21-22 | Rangers FC (English) | 7 (14) | James Tavernier | 38%
|
| Union Saint-Gilloise (Nigerian) | 6 (10) | Victor Boniface | 38%
| |
| 09-10 | SL Benfica (Paraguayan) | 9 (12) | Oscar Cardozo | 31%
|
| LOSC Lille (Turkish) | 7 (8) | Yusuf Yazici | 31%
| |
| FC Zenith (Brazilian) | 8 (8) | Giuliano | 25%
| |
| 20-21 | SL Benfica (Portuguese) | 7 (8) | Pizzi | 19%
|
| 14-15 | FC Salzburg (Brazilian) | 8 (5) | Alan | 13%
|
| AS Roma (Spanish) | 7 (13) | Borja Mayoral | 13%
| |
| 13-14 | FC Salzburg (Spanish) | 8 (7) | Jonatan Soriano | 13%
|
| FK Bodø/Glimt (Danish) | 7 (14) | Kasper Høgh | 13%
| |
| 12-13 | SS Lazio (Czech) | 8 (10) | Libor Kozák | 13%
|