| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Dated Topper and married John B | Sarah | 100%
|
| John B's best friend | JJ | 99%
|
| Big Johns Son | John B | 99%
|
| Sarahs ex boyfriend | Topper | 99%
|
| Killed Peterkin | Rafe | 97%
|
| Popes Crush | Kie/Kiara | 96%
|
| Heyward Son (the plan man) | Pope | 95%
|
| Wards wife | Rose | 92%
|
| Sheriff until shot | Peterkin | 85%
|
| "Blew up" on My Druthers | Ward | 83%
|
| Drug dealer | Barry | 82%
|
| Helped Sarah and John B in Nassau | Cleo | 81%
|
| Took over as sheriff | Shoupe | 71%
|
| Toppers best friend | Kelce | 55%
|
| Sarahs sister | Wheeize | 4%
|