| Hint | Extra Hint | Explanation | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mack the Knife | 5 October (6 wks.) 23 November (3 wks.) | Listen on YouTube | Bobby Darin | 88%
|
| Smoke Gets in Your Eyes | 19 January (3 wks.) | Listen on YouTube | The Platters | 88%
|
| A Big Hunk o' Love | 10 August (2 wks.) | Listen on YouTube | Elvis Presley | 82%
|
| The Battle of New Orleans | 1 June (6 wks.) | Listen on YouTube | Johnny Horton | 82%
|
| Venus | 9 March (5 wks.) | Listen on YouTube | Frankie Avalon | 65%
|
| Lonely Boy | 13 July (4 wks.) | Listen on YouTube | Paul Anka | 65%
|
| Sleep Walk | 21 September (2 wks.) | Listen on YouTube | Santo & Johnny | 65%
|
| Kansas City | 18 May (2 wks.) | Listen on YouTube | Wilbert Harrison | 65%
|
| Stagger Lee | 9 February (4 wks.) | Listen on YouTube Note: The clips in this video are from the film Shag (1989) starring Bridget Fonda, Phoebe Cates, Annabeth Gish, and Page Hannah. The film takes place in 1963, four years after this song charted as a hit, but the song has the right syncopation for the Carolina Shag — the name of a dance … not what you were thinking! | Lloyd Price | 59%
|
| Come Softly to Me | 13 April (4 wks.) | Listen on YouTube | The Fleetwoods | 59%
|
| The Happy Organ | 11 May (1 wk.) | Listen on YouTube | Dave "Baby" Cortez | 53%
|
| The Three Bells | 24 August (4 wks.) | Listen on YouTube | The Browns | 53%
|
| Why | 28 December (1 wk.) | Listen on YouTube | Frankie Avalon | 47%
|
| Mr. Blue | 16 November (1 wk.) | Listen on YouTube | The Fleetwoods | 47%
|
| Heartaches by the Number | 14 December (2 wks.) | Listen on YouTube | Guy Mitchell | 41%
|