| Hint | Extra Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lou | New York Yankees (1923-39) | Gehrig | 94%
|
| Pedro | Los Angeles Dodgers (1992-93), Montreal Expos (1994-97), Boston Red Sox (1998-2004), New York Mets (2005-08), Philadelphia Phillies (2009) | Martinez | 94%
|
| George “Babe” | Boston Red Sox (1914-19), New York Yankees (1920-34), Boston Braves (1935) | Ruth | 94%
|
| Mike | Los Angeles Angels (2011- ) | Trout | 94%
|
| Barry | Pittsburgh Pirates (1986-92), San Francisco Giants (1993-2007) | Bonds | 93%
|
| Ty | Detroit Tigers (1905-26), Philadelphia Athletics (1927-28) | Cobb | 93%
|
| Mickey | New York Yankees (1951-68) | Mantle | 93%
|
| Willie | Negro Leagues (1948, Birmingham Black Barons), New York/San Francisco Giants (1951-52, 1954-72), New York Mets (1972-73) | Mays | 93%
|
| Hank | Negro Leagues (1951, Indianapolis Clowns), Milwaukee/Atlanta Braves (1954-74), Milwaukee Brewers (1975-76) | Aaron | 91%
|
| Joe | New York Yankees (1936-51) | DiMaggio | 91%
|
| Ken | Seattle Mariners (1989-99, 2009-10), Cincinnati Reds (2000-08), Chicago White Sox (2008) | Griffey Jr. | 90%
|
| Rickey | Oakland Athletics (1979-84, 1989-93, 1994-95, 1998), New York Yankees (1985-89), Toronto Blue Jays (1993), San Diego Padres (1996-97, 2001), Anaheim Angels (1997), New York Mets (1999-2000), Seattle Mariners (2000), Boston Red Sox (2002), Los Angeles Dodgers (2003) | Henderson | 90%
|
| Stan | St. Louis Cardinals (1941-63) | Musial | 90%
|
| Tom | New York Mets (1967-77, 1983), Cincinnati Reds (1977-1982), Chicago White Sox (1984-86), Boston Red Sox (1986) | Seaver | 90%
|
| Honus | Louisville Colonels (1897-99), Pittsburgh Pirates (1900-1917) | Wagner | 90%
|
| Cy | Cleveland Spiders (1890-98), St. Louis Perfectos/Cardinals (1899-1900), Boston Americans/Red Sox (1901-08), Cleveland Naps (1909-11), Boston Rustlers (1911) | Young | 90%
|
| Randy | Montreal Expos (1988-89), Seattle Mariners (1989-1998), Houston Astros (1998), Arizona Diamondbacks (1999-2004, 2007-08), New York Yankees (2005-06), San Francisco Giants (2009) | Johnson | 88%
|
| Ted | Boston Red Sox (1939-42, 1946-60) | Williams | 87%
|
| Christy | New York Giants (1900-16), Cincinnati Reds (1916) | Mathewson | 82%
|
| Roger | Boston Red Sox (1984-96), Toronto Blue Jays (1997-98), New York Yankees (1999-2003, 2007), Houston Astros (2004-06) | Clemens | 81%
|
| Greg | Chicago Cubs (1986-92, 2004-06), Atlanta Braves (1993-2003), Los Angeles Dodgers (2006, 2008), San Diego Padres (2007-08) | Maddux | 81%
|
| Rogers | St. Louis Cardinals (1915-26, 1933), New York Giants (1927), Boston Braves (1928), Chicago Cubs (1929-32), St. Louis Browns (1933-37) | Hornsby | 78%
|
| Frank | Cincinnati Reds (1956-1965), Baltimore Orioles (1966-1971), Los Angeles Dodgers (1972), California Angels (1973-74), Cleveland Indians (1974-76) | Robinson | 78%
|
| Mike | Philadelphia Phillies (1972-1989) | Schmidt | 76%
|
| Walter | Washington Senators (1907-27) | Johnson | 65%
|