| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| [Ex]-Wife | Robin Scherbatsky | 95%
|
| Father | Robin Scherbatsky Senior | 94%
|
| Wife | Tracy McConnell | 89%
|
| Husband | Marshall Eriksen | 88%
|
| [Ex]-Husband | Barney Stinson | 83%
|
| Brother | Marvin Eriksen Junior | 81%
|
| Brother-In-Law | Marvin Eriksen Junior | 81%
|
| Father | Marvin Eriksen Senior | 81%
|
| Father-In-Law | Marvin Eriksen Senior | 81%
|
| Son | Marvin W. Eriksen | 81%
|
| Son | Marvin W. Eriksen | 81%
|
| Maternal Half-Brother | James Stinson | 75%
|
| Mother | Loretta Stinson | 68%
|
| Son | Luke Mosby | 66%
|
| Step-Father | Clint | 61%
|
| Wife | Lily Aldrin | 59%
|
| Father | Mickey Aldrin | 58%
|
| Daughter | Daisy Eriksen | 56%
|
| Daughter | Daisy Eriksen | 56%
|
| Daughter | Penny Mosby | 56%
|
| Sister | Heather Mosby | 48%
|
| Mother | Judy Eriksen | 48%
|
| Mother-In-Law | Judy Eriksen | 48%
|
| Father | Jerome Whittaker | 45%
|
| Mother | Virginia Mosby | 43%
|
| Brother | Marcus Eriksen | 41%
|
| Brother-in-Law | Marcus Eriksen | 41%
|
| Paternal Half-Brother | Jerome "JJ" Whittaker Junior | 39%
|
| Daughter | Ellie Stinson | 38%
|
| Brother-in-Law | Tom Stinson | 34%
|
| Paternal Half-Sister | Carly Whittaker | 21%
|
| Father | Alfred Mosby | 20%
|
| Sister | Katie Scherbatsky | 20%
|
| Mother | Janice Aldrin | 18%
|
| Mother | Genevieve Scherbatsky | 17%
|
| Niece | Sadie Stinson | 17%
|
| Nephew | Martin Eriksen | 16%
|
| Nephew | Martin Eriksen | 16%
|
| Paternal Grandmother | Rita Aldrin | 16%
|
| Nephew | Eli Stinson | 15%
|
| Paternal Grandfather | Morris Aldrin | 14%
|
| Paternal Grandfather | Olaf Eriksen | 12%
|
| Sister-in-Law | Ashley Eriksen | 11%
|
| Sister-in-law | Sarah Eriksen | 11%
|
| Step-Mother | Cheryl Whittaker | 8%
|
| Maternal Grandmother | Lois | 8%
|