| Pick | Team | Position | School | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 | CHC | C | Indiana | Kyle Schwarber | 67%
|
| 7 | PHI | P | LSU | Aaron Nola | 56%
|
| 8 | COL | P | Evansville | Kyle Freeland | 56%
|
| 1 | HOU | P | Cathedral Catholic HS | Brady Aiken | 44%
|
| 3 | CHW | P | NC State | Carlos Rodon | 44%
|
| 10 | NYM | OF | Oregon State | Michael Conforto | 44%
|
| 17 | KC | P | TCU | Brandon Finnegan | 33%
|
| 24 | PIT | SS | Mountain Pointe HS | Cole Tucker | 33%
|
| 34 | STL | P | Harvard-Westlake HS | Jack Flaherty | 33%
|
| 2 | MIA | P | Shepherd HS | Tyler Kolek | 33%
|
| 6 | SEA | C | Rancho Bernardo HS | Alex Jackson | 22%
|
| 36 | MIA | C | West Lauderdale HS | Blake Anderson | 22%
|
| 21 | CLE | OF | San Francisco | Bradley Zimmer | 22%
|
| 37 | HOU | OF | Virginia | Derek Fisher | 22%
|
| 23 | DET | OF | Elk Grove HS | Derek Hill | 22%
|
| 18 | WSH | P | UNLV | Erick Fedde | 22%
|
| 30 | TEX | P | Sanger HS | Luis Ortiz | 22%
|
| 25 | OAK | 3B | Cal State Fullerton | Matt Chapman | 22%
|
| 5 | MIN | SS | Olympia HS | Nick Gordon | 22%
|
| 13 | SD | SS | NC State | Trea Turner | 22%
|
| 29 | CIN | SS | Stanford | Alex Blandino | 11%
|
| 32 | ATL | OF | Roberson HS | Braxton Davidson | 11%
|
| 20 | TB | 1B | Wichita St | Casey Gillaspie | 11%
|
| 40 | KC | C | St. Thomas More HS | Chase Vallot | 11%
|
| 39 | PIT | OF | San Diego | Connor Joe | 11%
|
| 35 | COL | 2B | Orangewood Christian HS | Forrest Wall | 11%
|
| 28 | KC | P | The First Academy | Foster Griffin | 11%
|
| 22 | LAD | P | Conway HS | Grant Holmes | 11%
|
| 41 | MIL | SS | Clovis HS | Jacob Gatewood | 11%
|
| 9 | TOR | P | East Carolina | Jeff Hoffman | 11%
|
| 31 | CLE | P | Tullahoma HS | Justus Sheffield | 11%
|
| 12 | MIL | P | Waiakea HS | Kodi Medeiros | 11%
|
| 27 | STL | P | Florida State | Luke Weaver | 11%
|
| 11 | TOR | C | Kennesaw State | Max Pentecost | 11%
|
| 26 | BOS | SS | Sprayberry HS | Michael Chavis | 11%
|
| 33 | BOS | P | Mount Pleasant HS | Michael Kopech | 11%
|
| 38 | CLE | OF | Virginia | Mike Papi | 11%
|
| 19 | CIN | P | Virginia | Nick Howard | 11%
|
| 15 | LAA | P | Hartford | Sean Newcomb | 11%
|
| 16 | AZ | P | Coral Springs Charter HS | Touki Toussaint | 11%
|
| 14 | SF | P | Vanderbilt | Tyler Beede | 11%
|