| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Sherrif Gray | Arthur Morgan/Micah Bell | 99%
|
| Angelo Bronte | Dutch Van Der Linde | 97%
|
| Leviticus Cornwall | Dutch Van Der Linde | 97%
|
| Micah Bell | John Marston/Dutch Van Der Linde | 97%
|
| Laramie Boss | John Marston | 94%
|
| Joe | John Marston | 94%
|
| De Santa | John Marston | 94%
|
| Bill Williamson | John Marston | 94%
|
| Javier Escuella | John Marston/Executed | 94%
|
| Cleet | John Marston/Sadie Adler | 94%
|
| Agent Ross | Jack Marston | 85%
|
| Agent Milton | Abigail Roberts | 69%
|
| Dutch Van Der Linde | Himself | 44%
|
| Catherine Braithwaite | Herself | 35%
|
| Colm O'Driscoll | Hangman | 7%
|