| Letter | Song | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| H | Hallelujah | Hey Look Ma, I Made It | High Hopes | House of Memories | Hurricane | 93%
|
| T | That Green Gentleman | The Ballad of Mona Lisa | The Calendar | The End of All Things | The Good, The Bad and The Dirty | The Only Difference Between Martyrdom and Suicide Is Press Coverage | The Overpass | The Piano Knows Something I Don’t Know | There's a Good Reason These Tables Are Numbered Honey, You Just Haven't Thought of It Yet | This Is Gospel | Time to Dance | Trade Mistakes |Turn Off the Lights | 93%
|
| N | Nails for Breakfast, Tacks for Snacks | Nearly Witches (Ever Since We Met...) | New Perspective | Nicotine | Nine in the Afternoon | Northern Downpour | 87%
|
| D | Dancing's Not a Crime | Death of a Bachelor | Do It To Death | Do You Know What I'm Seeing? | Don't Let the Light Go Out | Don’t Threaten Me With a Good Time | Dying in LA | 86%
|
| I | I Constantly Thank God for Esteban | I Have Friends in Holy Spaces | I Wanna Be Free | I Write Sins Not Tragedies | Impossible Year | Intermission | Introduction | 81%
|
| L | LA Devotee | Let's Kill Tonight | Local God | London Beckoned Songs About Money Written by Machines | Lying Is the Most Fun a Girl Can Have Without Taking Her Clothes Off | 81%
|
| S | Sad Clown | Sarah Smiles | Say Amen (Saturday Night) | Say It Louder | She's a Handsome Woman | She Had the World | Something About Maggie | Stall Me | Star-Spangled Banger | Sugar Soaker | 80%
|
| C | Camisado | Can't Fight Against the Youth | Casual Affair | Collar Full | Crazy = Genius | 79%
|
| V | Vegas Lights | Victorious | Viva Las Vengeance | 79%
|
| M | Mad as Rabbits | Memories | Middle of a Breakup | Miss Jackson | 73%
|
| B | Behind the Sea | Bittersweet | Build God, Then We'll Talk | But It's Better If You Do | 72%
|
| G | Girl That You Love | Girls/Girls/Boys | God Killed Rock and Roll | Golden Days | 67%
|
| R | Ready to Go (Get Me Out of My Mind) | Roaring 20s | 55%
|
| E | Emperor's New Clothes | 51%
|
| A | All By Myself | All the Boys | Always | 48%
|
| K | Kaleidoscope Eyes | King of the Clouds | 48%
|
| F | Far Too Young to Die | Folkin' Around | From a Mountain in the Middle of the Cabins | (Fuck A) Silver Lining | 47%
|
| O | Oh Glory | Old Fashioned | One of the Drunks | 41%
|
| P | Pas de Cheval | 35%
|
| W | We're So Starving | When the Day Meets the Night | 24%
|