| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Cursed Monkey | Jack | 91%
|
| Blacksmith turned Pirate | Will Turner | 88%
|
| Captain of the Black Pearl | Jack Sparrow | 82%
|
| Captain of the Flying Dutchman | Davy Jones | 65%
|
| Cursed Pirate, nicknamed "Bootstrap" | Bill Turner | 56%
|
| Widow turned Pirate | Elizabeth Swann | 53%
|
| Former Captain of the Black Pearl | Hector Barbossa | 50%
|
| Mute Pirate | Cotton | 47%
|
| Obeah Woman, Human form of Calypso | Tia Dalma | 44%
|
| Governor of Port Royal | Weatherby Swann | 41%
|
| Lord of the East India Trading Company | Cutler Beckett | 38%
|
| Former Commodore of the Royal Navy | James Norrington | 38%
|
| Scandinavian Beast with a Potent Stench | Kraken | 38%
|
| Robust Pirate Uncle of the Character above | Pintel | 38%
|
| Lanky Pirate with a Wooden Eye | Ragetti | 38%
|
| Parrot that speaks in Cryptic Phrases | Cotton's Parrot | 32%
|
| First Mate aboard the Black Pearl | Joshamee Gibbs | 32%
|
| Little Pirate | Marty | 26%
|
| Scottish Spy of the East India Trading Company | Ian Mercer | 24%
|
| First Mate aboard the Flying Dutchman | Maccus | 18%
|
| Dog holding a Key Ring | Poochie | 9%
|
| Cursed Pirate embedded in the Flying Dutchman | Wyvern | 9%
|
| Cursed Pirate with a Crab attached to his Head | Hadras | 6%
|
| Bo'sun of the Flying Dutchman | Jimmy Legs | 6%
|
| Indian Pirate aboard the Black Pearl | Leech | 6%
|