| Players/Coaches (Team) | Retired Jersey # | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Harmon Killebrew (Twins), Dale Murphy (Braves), Babe Ruth (Yankees) | 3 | 98%
|
| Mariano Rivera (Yankees), Jackie Robinson (all teams), Bruce Sutter (Cardinals) | 42 | 85%
|
| Cal Ripken (Orioles), Willie Stargell (Pirates), Carl Yastrzemski (Red Sox) | 8 | 79%
|
| Nellie Fox (White Sox), Derek Jeter (Yankees), Tommy Lasorda (Dodgers) | 2 | 77%
|
| Lou Gehrig (Yankees), Ralph Kiner (Pirates), Paul Molitor (Brewers) | 4 | 76%
|
| Hank Aaron (Braves/Brewers), Reggie Jackson (Yankees), Willie McCovey (Giants) | 44 | 73%
|
| Ken Griffey, Jr. (Mariners), Rickey Henderson (A's), Willie Mays (Giants) | 24 | 72%
|
| Bob Feller (Indians), Tony Gwynn (Padres), Robin Yount (Brewers) | 19 | 65%
|
| David Ortiz (Red Sox), Kirby Puckett (Twins), Nolan Ryan (Rangers/Astros) | 34 | 65%
|
| Ernie Banks (Cubs), Gil Hodges (Dodgers), Pete Rose (Reds) | 14 | 62%
|
| Greg Maddux (Cubs/Braves), Mike Piazza (Mets), Dave Winfield (Padres) | 31 | 61%
|
| Reggie Jackson (A's), Minnie Minosa (White Sox), Ted Williams (Red Sox) | 9 | 56%
|
| Johnny Bench (Reds), Hank Greenberg (Tigers), Brooks Robinson (Orioles) | 5 | 55%
|
| Roberto Clemente (Pirates), Bob Lemon (Indians), Warren Spahn (Braves) | 21 | 54%
|
| Bobby Cox (Braves), Al Kaline (Tigers), Stan Musial (Cardinals) | 6 | 54%
|
| Frank Robinson (Indians), Frank Robinson (Orioles), Frank Robinson (Reds) | 20 | 43%
|
| Carlton Fisk (Red Sox), Catfish Hunter (A's), Juan Marichal (Giants) | 27 | 40%
|