| First Name | Last Name | Team (Year) | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Satchel | Paige | Negro Leagues (1927-47), Indians (1948-49), Browns (1951-53), A's (1965) | 97%
|
| Yadier | Molina | Cardinals (2004-22) | 94%
|
| Gaylord | Perry | Virtually everybody (1962-83) | 94%
|
| Vida | Blue | A's (1969-77), Giants (1978-81, 1985-86), Royals (1982-83) | 90%
|
| Nap | Lajoie | Phillies (1896-1900), A's (1901-02, 1915-16), Indians (1902-14) | 87%
|
| Tris | Speaker | Red Sox (1907-15), Indians (1916-26), Senators (1927), A's (1928) | 84%
|
| Kenley | Jansen | Dodgers (2010-present) | 81%
|
| Nellie | Fox | A's (1947-49), White Sox (1950-63), Astros (1964-65) | 71%
|
| Gorman | Thomas | Brewers (1973-83, 1986), Indians (1983), Mariners (1984-86) | 65%
|
| Bake | McBride | Cardinals (1973-77), Phillies (1977-81), Indians (1982-83) | 55%
|
| Tyrus | Cobb | Tigers (1905-26), A's (1927-28) | 52%
|
| Homer | Bailey | Reds (2007-present) | 48%
|
| Dellin | Betances | Yankees (2011-present) | 45%
|
| Gates | Brown | Tigers (1963-75) | 45%
|
| Heinie | Manush | Tigers (1923-27), Browns (1928-30), Senators (1930-35), Red Sox (1936), Dodgers (1937-38), Pirates (1938-39) | 39%
|
| Lyman | Bostock | Twins (1975-77), Angels (1978) | 35%
|
| Sixto | Lezcano | Brewers (1974-80), Cardinals (1981), Padres (1982-83), Phillies (1983-84), Pirates (1985) | 35%
|
| Elroy | Face | Pirates (1953-68), Tigers (1968), Expos (1969) | 32%
|
| Moose | Haas | Brewers (1976-85), A's (1986-87) | 26%
|
| Bombo | Rivera | Expos (1975-76), Twins (1978-80), Royals (1982) | 6%
|