| Year | Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2000 | New York Yankees | Derek Jeter | 84%
|
| 2013 | Boston Red Sox | David Ortiz | 81%
|
| 2001 | Arizona Diamondbacks | Randy Johnson | 71%
|
| 2014 | San Francisco Giants | Madison Bumgarner | 70%
|
| 1970 | Baltimore Orioles | Brooks Robinson | 62%
|
| 1966 | Baltimore Orioles | Frank Robinson | 62%
|
| 1977 | New York Yankees | Reggie Jackson | 62%
|
| 1973 | Oakland Athletics | Reggie Jackson | 62%
|
| 2001 | Arizona Diamondbacks | Curt Schilling | 59%
|
| 2015 | Kansas City Royals | Salvador Perez | 59%
|
| 1967 | St. Louis Cardinals | Bob Gibson | 58%
|
| 1964 | St. Louis Cardinals | Bob Gibson | 58%
|
| 1999 | New York Yankees | Mariano Rivera | 58%
|
| 2011 | St. Louis Cardinals | David Freese | 57%
|
| 1976 | Cincinnati Reds | Johnny Bench | 54%
|
| 1975 | Cincinnati Reds | Pete Rose | 53%
|
| 1965 | Los Angeles Dodgers | Sandy Koufax | 52%
|
| 1963 | Los Angeles Dodgers | Sandy Koufax | 52%
|
| 2012 | San Francisco Giants | Pablo Sandoval | 48%
|
| 2004 | Boston Red Sox | Manny Ramirez | 47%
|
| 1971 | Pittsburgh Pirates | Roberto Clemente | 47%
|
| 1979 | Pittsburgh Pirates | Willie Stargell | 47%
|
| 1995 | Atlanta Braves | Tom Glavine | 45%
|
| 1980 | Philadelphia Phillies | Mike Schmidt | 44%
|
| 1991 | Minnesota Twins | Jack Morris | 41%
|
| 2009 | New York Yankees | Hideki Matsui | 40%
|
| 2003 | Florida Marlins | Josh Beckett | 40%
|
| 1997 | Florida Marlins | Livan Hernandez | 38%
|
| 1961 | New York Yankees | Whitey Ford | 38%
|
| 1988 | Los Angeles Dodgers | Orel Hershiser | 37%
|
| 2008 | Philadelphia Phillies | Cole Hamels | 34%
|
| 1984 | Detroit Tigers | Alan Trammell | 31%
|
| 1985 | Kansas City Royals | Bret Saberhagen | 31%
|
| 1993 | Toronto Blue Jays | Paul Molitor | 31%
|
| 2002 | Anaheim Angels | Troy Glaus | 30%
|
| 1989 | Oakland Athletics | Dave Stewart | 29%
|
| 2010 | San Francisco Giants | Edgar Renteria | 28%
|
| 1998 | New York Yankees | Scott Brosius | 28%
|
| 1986 | New York Mets | Ray Knight | 27%
|
| 1974 | Oakland Athletics | Rollie Fingers | 27%
|
| 2006 | St. Louis Cardinals | David Eckstein | 25%
|
| 2005 | Chicago White Sox | Jermaine Dye | 25%
|
| 1981 | Los Angeles Dodgers | Ron Cey | 25%
|
| 2007 | Boston Red Sox | Mike Lowell | 24%
|
| 1987 | Minnesota Twins | Frank Viola | 23%
|
| 1990 | Cincinnati Reds | Jose Rijo | 23%
|
| 1981 | Los Angeles Dodgers | Pedro Guerrero | 22%
|
| 1978 | New York Yankees | Bucky Dent | 21%
|
| 1956 | New York Yankees | Don Larsen | 21%
|
| 1968 | Detroit Tigers | Mickey Lolich | 21%
|
| 1996 | New York Yankees | John Wetteland | 20%
|
| 1960 | New York Yankees | Bobby Richardson | 19%
|
| 1972 | Oakland Athletics | Gene Tenace | 18%
|
| 1992 | Toronto Blue Jays | Pat Borders | 17%
|
| 1983 | Baltimore Orioles | Rick Dempsey | 17%
|
| 1981 | Los Angeles Dodgers | Steve Yeager | 16%
|
| 1955 | Brooklyn Dodgers | Johnny Podres | 15%
|
| 1982 | St. Louis Cardinals | Darrell Porter | 14%
|
| 1969 | New York Mets | Donn Clendenon | 13%
|
| 1962 | New York Yankees | Ralph Terry | 11%
|
| 1957 | Milwaukee Braves | Lew Burdette | 10%
|
| 1958 | New York Yankees | Bob Turley | 9%
|
| 1959 | Los Angeles Dodgers | Larry Sherry | 8%
|