| Hint | Extra Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| how does he sleep? | "go to sleep" | Jeff the Killer | 80%
|
| she loves jeff | "go to sleep, my prince" | Nina the Killer | 80%
|
| animal thing with claws | "he is the rake" | The Rake | 78%
|
| a creepy canine PNG | "spread the word" | Smile Dog | 75%
|
| if link was evil and dead | "you shouldn't have done that" | BenDrowned | 74%
|
| little girl who got raped by her uncle | "play with me" | Sally Williams | 71%
|
| he'll eatcha kidneys | "just empty, black sockets" | Eyeless Jack | 70%
|
| tall, dark and creepy | "always watching - no eyes" | Slenderman | 70%
|
| monochrome pennywise | "do you want some candy, kiddo?" | Laughing Jack | 68%
|
| she hates jeff | "don't go to sleep. you won't wake up" | Jane | 67%
|
| watch in her eyeball | "your time is up" | Clockwork | 61%
|
| brother with the green scarf | "it's a wonderful day to kill" | Homicidal Liu | 57%
|
| yellow jacket proxy | "he is a liar" | Hoodie | 55%
|
| waffle boy | "who needs a social life when you have the voices in your head to keep you company?" | Ticci Toby | 53%
|
| annoyed by toby | "he is a liar" | Masky | 42%
|