| Person | Island | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Blackbeard | Great Britain | 89%
|
| Bear Grylls | Ireland | 81%
|
| Papa Doc | Hispaniola | 69%
|
| Linford Christie | Jamaica | 64%
|
| Pygmalion | Cyprus | 58%
|
| Kiri Te Kanawa | North Island | 50%
|
| Carlos Moyá | Mallorca | 44%
|
| Anthony Minghella | Isle of Wight | 42%
|
| Bette Midler | Oahu | 33%
|
| Benicio del Toro | Puerto Rico | 33%
|
| Errol Flynn | Tasmania | 33%
|
| Cornelius Vanderbilt | Staten Island | 31%
|
| Derek Walcott | Saint Lucia | 22%
|
| Antonio Vivaldi | Venice | 22%
|
| Hayreddin Barbarossa | Lesbos | 17%
|
| Maurice Bishop | Aruba | 11%
|
| Chris Horner | Okinawa | 11%
|
| Charles Dickens | Portsea Island | 8%
|
| Juan de Fuca | Cephalonia | 3%
|
| Mikis Theodorakis | Chios | 3%
|