| Musical | Hint | Character | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Les Miserables | Stole a loaf of bread | Jean Valjean | 84%
|
| Hamilton | The damn fool that shot him | Aaron Burr | 76%
|
| Phantom of the Opera | Got kidnapped | Christine Daae | 71%
|
| Mamma Mia | Bangs three guys in one summer | Donna Sheridan | 60%
|
| Sweeny Todd | Bakes the worst pies in london | Mrs Lovett | 43%
|
| Little Shop of Horrors | "Feed me, Seymour!" | Audrey II | 36%
|
| Dear Evan Hansen | "Kinky!" | Jared Kleinman | 34%
|
| Be More Chill | He makes an enterance | Michael Mell | 29%
|
| Cats | He's Magical | Mr Mistoffelees | 24%
|
| Wicked | School Reject | Fiyero | 21%
|
| Jekyll and Hyde | Engaged to the doctor | Lisa/Emma Carew | 8%
|
| Love Never Dies | Phantom Jr | Gustave de Chagny | 3%
|