| Team | Position | Number | Years Active | Answer | % Correct | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2. | Baltimore Orioles | SS/3B | 8 | 1981-2001 | Cal Ripken Jr. | 95%
|
| 6. | Boston Red Sox | LF | 9 | 1939-1942 1946-1960 | Ted Williams | 91%
|
| 3. | Baltimore Orioles | 3B | 5 | 1955-1977 | Brooks Robinson | 90%
|
| 9. | Brooklyn Dodgers | 2B | 42 | 1947-1956 | Jackie Robinson | 90%
|
| 26. | Kansas City Royals | 3B/DH/1B | 5 | 1973-1993 | George Brett | 78%
|
| 1. | Baltimore Orioles | P | 22 | 1965-1967 1969-1984 | Jim Palmer | 78%
|
| 11. | Brooklyn/LA Dodgers | P | 32 | 1955-1966 | Sandy Koufax | 78%
|
| 13. | Chicago Cubs | SS/1B | 14 | 1953-1971 | Ernie Banks | 76%
|
| 39. | New York Yankees | CF | 7 | 1951-1968 | Mickey Mantle | 76%
|
| 18. | Cincinnati Reds | C | 5 | 1967-1983 | Johnny Bench | 75%
|
| 25. | Houston Astros | 2B/C | 7 | 1988-2007 | Craig Biggio | 71%
|
| 24. | Houston Astros | 1B | 5 | 1991-2005 | Jeff Bagwell | 71%
|
| 38. | New York Yankees | 1B | 4 | 1923-1939 | Lou Gehrig | 71%
|
| 27. | Milwaukee Brewers | SS/CF | 19 | 1974-1993 | Robin Yount | 71%
|
| 36. | New York Yankees | CF | 5 | 1936-1942 1946-1951 | Joe DiMaggio | 69%
|
| 12. | Brooklyn/LA Dodgers | SS | 1 | 1940-1942 1946-1958 | Pee Wee Reese | 67%
|
| 28. | Minnesota Twins | CF | 34 | 1984-1995 | Kirby Puckett | 66%
|
| 42. | Pittsburgh Pirates | RF | 21 | 1955-1972 | Roberto Clemente | 66%
|
| 20. | Cleveland Indians | P | 19 | 1936-1941 1945-1956 | Bob Feller | 64%
|
| 41. | Philadelphia Phillies | 3B | 20 | 1972-1989 | Mike Schmidt | 64%
|
| 19. | Cincinnati Reds | SS | 11 | 1986-2004 | Barry Larkin | 62%
|
| 23. | Detroit Tigers | RF | 6 | 1953-1974 | Al Kaline | 60%
|
| 8. | Brooklyn Dodgers | C | 39 | 1948-1957 | Roy Campanella | 60%
|
| 46. | San Diego Padres | RF | 19 | 1982-2001 | Tony Gwynn | 60%
|
| 48. | St. Louis Cardinals | OF/1B | 6 | 1941-1944 1946-1963 | Stan Musial | 59%
|
| 49. | Washington Senators | P | 1907-1927 | Walter Johnson | 58%
| |
| 5. | Boston Red Sox | LF/DH | 14 | 1974-1989 | Jim Rice | 56%
|
| 37. | New York Yankees | P | 16 | 1950 1953-1967 | Whitey Ford | 55%
|
| 44. | Pittsburgh Pirates | LF/1B | 8 | 1962-1982 | Willie Stargell | 54%
|
| 10. | Brooklyn/LA Dodgers | P | 53 | 1956-1969 | Don Drysdale | 52%
|
| 47. | St. Louis Cardinals | P | 45 | 1959-1975 | Bob Gibson | 51%
|
| 7. | Boston Red Sox | LF/1B | 8 | 1961-1983 | Carl Yastrzemski | 46%
|
| 31. | New York Giants | RF | 4 | 1926-1947 | Mel Ott | 39%
|
| 40. | New York Yankees | SS | 10 | 1941-1942 1946-1956 | Phil Rizzuto | 34%
|
| 4. | Boston Red Sox | 2B | 1 | 1937-1944 1946-1951 | Bobby Doerr | 31%
|
| 14. | Chicago White Sox | SS | 4 | 1930-1943 1945-1950 | Luke Appling | 30%
|
| 35. | New York Yankees | C | 8 | 1928-1943 1946 | Bill Dickey | 28%
|
| 43. | Pittsburgh Pirates | 2B | 9 | 1956-1972 | Bill Mazeroski | 28%
|
| 22. | Detroit Tigers | 2B | 2 | 1924-1942 | Charlie Gehringer | 26%
|
| 29. | New York Giants | P | 11 | 1928-1943 | Carl Hubbell | 22%
|
| 30. | New York Giants | SS | 5 | 1922-1936 | Travis Jackson | 22%
|
| 21. | Cleveland Indians | P | 21 | 1941-1942 1946-1958 | Bob Lemon | 21%
|
| 45. | Pittsburgh Pirates | 3B | 20 | 1920-1935 1937 | Pie Traynor | 14%
|
| 32. | New York Giants | 1B | 3 | 1923-1936 | Bill Terry | 13%
|
| 34. | New York Yankees | CF | 1 | 1924-1935 | Earle Combs | 13%
|
| 16. | Chicago White Sox | P | 16 | 1923-1942, 1946 | Ted Lyons | 12%
|
| 17. | Cincinnati Stockings/Reds | 2B | 1882-1899 | Bid McPhee | 9%
| |
| 15. | Chicago White Sox | P | 18 | 1914-1933 | Red Faber | 5%
|
| 33. | New York Giants | RF | 1917-1926 | Ross Youngs | 3%
|