| Song | Answer | Explanation | % Correct | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 14 | The Dark Elf | T | Maeglin is born | 79%
|
| 6 | The Curse of Fëanor | A | Fëanor, after burning the ships at Losgar | 71%
|
| 3 | Lammoth | U | Morgoth's anguished cry | 65%
|
| 5 | The Minstrel | B | Maglor (most probably), waiting for how events will turn up | 62%
|
| 7 | Captured | F | Morgoth's words to Maedhros after his capture | 62%
|
| 1 | War of Wrath | P | Sauron and Morgoth's last words before the former flees | 60%
|
| 8 | Blood Tears | G | Fingon rescues Maedhros from the precipice | 56%
|
| 2 | Into the Storm | S | Morgoth and Ungoliant fight for the Silmarils | 56%
|
| 18 | When Sorrow Sang | M | Beren dies, but Lúthien sings before Mandos and moves him to tears | 54%
|
| 13 | Time Stands Still (At the Iron Hill) | E | The duel between Fingolfin and Morgoth | 52%
|
| 4 | Nightfall | H | Fëanor argues with the Valar and takes the Noldor with him to Beleriand | 48%
|
| 11 | Noldor (Dead Winter Reigns) | Q | Fingolfin crossing the Helcaraxë, including the Doom of Mandos | 48%
|
| 9 | Mirror Mirror | K | Turgon retreats to Gondolin, Ulmo warns him not to love the work of his hands too much. | 46%
|
| 15 | Thorn | V | Maeglin betrays Gondolin. | 44%
|
| 23 | Harvest of Sorrow | W | Túrin Turambar learns of his sister's death | 44%
|
| 17 | Nom the Wise | J | Beren cries Felagund's death | 42%
|
| 10 | Face the Truth | N | Fingolfin and his host finish the crossing of the Helcaraxe as the first moon rises | 40%
|
| 20 | The Steadfast | C | Morgoth proclaims his victory after the Nirnaeth Arnoediad | 38%
|
| 19 | Out on the Water | I | Beren and Lúthien live their second lives on an island | 38%
|
| 16 | The Eldar | L | Finrod Felagund's farewell before his death | 38%
|
| 21 | A Dark Passage | O | Morgoth's words to Húrin after his capture | 35%
|
| 12 | Battle of Sudden Flame | D | Finrod makes an oath of friendship and aid to Barahir and his kin | 31%
|
| 22 | Final Chapter (Thus Ends...) | R | A reference to the words Huor told Turgon when covering his retreat | 27%
|