| Player | Number | Position | MLB Team | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Austin Wells | 28 | C | Yankees | 93%
|
| Vladimir Guerrero Jr | 27 | INF | Blue Jays | 88%
|
| Junior Caminero | 13 | INF | Rays | 83%
|
| Ketel Marte | 4 | INF | Diamondbacks | 83%
|
| Manny Machado | 3 | INF | Padres | 80%
|
| Fernando Tatis | 23 | INF | Padres | 78%
|
| Julio Rodriguez | 44 | INF | Mariners | 78%
|
| Geraldo Perdomo | 2 | INF | Diamondbacks | 76%
|
| Oneil Cruz | 15 | INF | Pirates | 76%
|
| Juan Soto | 22 | INF | Mets | 71%
|
| Gregory Soto | 65 | P | Pirates | 68%
|
| Agustin Ramirez | 50 | C | Marlins | 54%
|
| Albert Pujols | 5 | Manager | Cardinals/Angels | 54%
|
| Cristopher Sanchez | 61 | P | Phillies | 49%
|
| Sandy Alcantara | 7 | P | Marlins | 49%
|
| Luis Severino | 40 | P | Athletics | 44%
|
| Wandy Peralta | 59 | P | Padres | 29%
|
| Brayan Bello | 66 | P | Red Sox | 27%
|
| Seranthony Dominguez | 48 | P | White Sox | 27%
|
| Abner Uribe | 45 | P | Brewers | 20%
|
| Carlos Santana | 41 | INF | Diamondbacks | 20%
|
| Dennis Santana | 60 | P | Pirates | 20%
|
| Amed Rosario | 14 | INF | Yankees | 17%
|
| Carlos Estevez | 53 | P | Royals | 15%
|
| Erik Gonzalez | 11 | INF | Reds | 15%
|
| Albert Abreu | 54 | P | Reds | 12%
|
| Camilo Doval | 75 | P | White Sox | 12%
|
| Huascar Brazoban | 43 | P | Mets | 12%
|
| Elvis Alvarado | 37 | P | Athletics | 10%
|
| Junior Lake | 82 | INF | Mariners | 5%
|
| Juan Mejia | 47 | P | Rockies | 0%
|