| Creepypasta Name | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| "Go. To. Sleep" | Jeff The Killer | 98%
|
| Swore to get revenge against Jeff the Killer | Jane the Killer | 90%
|
| From a video game | Ben_Drowned | 87%
|
| No eyes, but always watching | Slenderman | 87%
|
| She was abused by her father | Sally Williams | 83%
|
| "Just empty black sockets..." | Eyeless Jack | 80%
|
| Used to be colorful, now a monochrome being | Laughing Jack | 79%
|
| "Spread the word" | Smile Dog | 77%
|
| A human like creature. It's name is also a gardening tool | The Rake | 77%
|
| His brother tried to murder him | Homicidal Liu | 72%
|
| Creative, artistic yet deadly. He was bullied. | Bloody Painter | 70%
|
| The god of minecraft | Herobrine | 70%
|
| A character from Marble Hornets... And a friend of Brian's... | Masky | 66%
|
| "Your time is up" | Clockwork | 60%
|
| From Spongebob... can't be that scary right...? | Squidward | 60%
|
| Silent, kills only when ordered, and extremely loyal to slenderman | Hoodie | 59%
|
| Always numb to pain... | Ticci Toby | 59%
|
| "He comes" | Zalgo | 48%
|
| "Give me your eyes..." | Lulu | 46%
|
| "He died" | Lost Silver | 43%
|
| A "cheerful" fruit | Happy Appy | 35%
|
| Last question: Where does Slenderman and his Proxy's and most of the other Creepypasta's live? (Yep. This determines is you are truly a fan or not.) | The Slender Mansion | 34%
|
| My Little Pony. Pinkie Pie. | Cupcake | 23%
|
| Pokemon.. Lavender... Ghost... | Lavender Town Ghost | 17%
|
| A little like the monochrome clown... but female... 0 | Zero | 15%
|
| Controlling... Boi... | The Puppeteer | 12%
|
| "Am i a joke to you?" | Glitchy Red | 9%
|