| Home Runs | Primary Team(s) | Final Season | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 536 | Yankees | 1968 (HOF) | Mickey Mantle | 100%
|
| 468 | Braves | 2012 (HOF) | Chipper Jones | 88%
|
| 504 | Orioles | 1997 (HOF) | Eddie Murray | 88%
|
| 285 | Indians | Active in 2025 | Jose Ramirez | 63%
|
| 435 | Mets/Royals | 2017 (HOF) | Carlos Beltran | 50%
|
| 287 | Yankees | 2006 | Bernie Williams | 38%
|
| 275 | Yankees | 2011 | Jorge Posada | 38%
|
| 409 | Yankees | 2016 | Mark Teixeira | 38%
|
| 314 | Red Sox | 1982 | Reggie Smith | 38%
|
| 248 | Cardinals | 1988 (HOF) | Ted Simmons | 38%
|
| 335 | Indians | Active in 2025 | Carlos Santana | 25%
|
| 279 | Indians | Active in 2025 | Francisco Lindor | 25%
|
| 246 | Orioles | 1984 | Ken Singleton | 25%
|
| 366 | Astros | 2013 | Lance Berkman | 25%
|
| 287 | Pirates | 2001 | Bobby Bonilla | 13%
|
| 350 | Angels/Giants | 1999 | Chili Davis | 13%
|
| 246 | Indians | 2018 | Victor Martinez | 13%
|
| 249 | Brewers | 2007 | Jose Valentin | 0%
|
| 306 | Rangers | 2006 | Ruben Sierra | 0%
|
| 251 | Tigers | 2009 | Tony Clark | 0%
|