| Nickname | Tenure | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hammerin' Hank | 1954–1974 | Hank Aaron | 98%
|
| Chipper | 1993–2012 | Larry "Chipper" Jones | 98%
|
| The Curaçao Kid | 1996–2007 | Andruw Jones | 94%
|
| The Professor / Mad Dog | 1993–2003 | Greg Maddux | 90%
|
| The Murph / All-American Boy | 1976–1990 | Dale Murphy | 89%
|
| Knucksie | 1964–1983 | Phil Niekro | 77%
|
| La Bestia | 2018– | Ronald Acuña Jr. | 77%
|
| Crime Dog | 1993–1997 | Fred McGriff | 74%
|
| Dusty | 1968–1975 | Johnnie "Dusty" Baker | 71%
|
| The Big Bear | 2020– | Marcell Ozuna | 69%
|
| Marmaduke | 1988–2008 | John Smoltz | 58%
|
| Frenchy | 2005–2009 | Jeff Francoeur | 52%
|
| The Brookfield Bomber | 1952–1966 | Eddie Mathews | 44%
|
| Hooks / The Invincible One | 1942–1964 | Warren Spahn | 40%
|
| Lemmer | 1988–1997 | Mark Lemke | 37%
|
| Roadrunner / Gator | 1968–1975 | Ralph Garr | 19%
|
| Bedrock | 1981–1985 | Steve Bedrosian | 19%
|