| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Reds player with the most hits in MLB history | Pete Rose | 96%
|
| Nickname of the dominant Reds squad from the 1970s | Big Red {Machine} | 93%
|
| Catcher with the most home runs in team history | Johnny Bench | 90%
|
| Pitcher who, in 2010, threw the fastest pitch in baseball history (105.8 mph) | Aroldis Chapman | 86%
|
| Reds player from 2007–2023 with an impressive .409 career on base percentage | Joey Votto | 86%
|
| Hall of Famer who hit his 500th home run in 2004 with his father (a former Red) watching from the stands | Ken Griffey Jr., | 86%
|
| In 2023, this shortstop stole second, third, and home in the same inning | Elly De La Cruz | 84%
|
| Star shortstop from 1986–2004 | Barry Larkin | 74%
|
| Hall of Fame second baseman who played with the Reds from 1972–1979 | Joe Morgan | 72%
|
| "Big Donkey" who hit exactly 40 home runs four years in a row from 2005–2008 | Adam Dunn | 63%
|
| Reds' stadium from 1970–2002 | {Riverfront} Stadium | 61%
|
| Reds manager from 1970–1978 | Sparky Anderson | 55%
|
| Controversial former team owner who let her Saint Bernards poop on the field | Marge Schott | 54%
|
| Slugger who set a team record with 52 home runs in 1977 | George Foster | 47%
|