| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Name of the team before 2021 | Cleveland {Indians} | 100%
|
| 1989 movie about the team starring Charlie Sheen and Wesley Snipes | Major League | 90%
|
| Team leader in career home runs | Jim Thome | 84%
|
| Current pitcher who shares his last name with a Canadian pop singer | Shane Bieber | 82%
|
| What you could buy at Cleveland Stadium for just 10 cents on the infamousnight of June 4, 1974 | Beer | 81%
|
| Last name of former players Roberto and Sandy | Alomar | 80%
|
| Former team logo considered offensive by many | Chief {Wahoo} | 78%
|
| Player who hit 34 home runs in 2016 and who shares his first and last name with a Mexican guitarist | Carlos Santana | 70%
|
| Sluggish slugger who had 165 RBIs in 1999 – the most of any player in the Major Leagues since 1938 | Manny Ramirez | 70%
|
| Original name of the Guardians stadium when it opened in 1994 | {Jacobs} Field | 66%
|
| The first player in team history to hit 50 home runs in a season (1995) | Albert Belle | 65%
|
| Negro League star pitcher who, at 42 years of age, was the oldest rookie in Major League history | Satchel Paige | 65%
|
| Speedster who stole 452 bases between 1992–2007 | Kenny Lofton | 63%
|
| Shortstop who won 8 Gold Glove awards between 1994–2004 | Omar Vizquel | 63%
|
| Flamethrowing pitcher known as "Rapid Robert" and "Bullet Bob" | Bob Feller | 61%
|
| Second basemen who was so good they actually named the team for him from 1903–1914 | Nap Lajoie | 53%
|
| 1972 Cy Young winner famous for throwing spitballs | Gaylord Perry | 37%
|
| Player who was traded to the Tigers in 1960, causing the team to be cursed since | Rocky Colavito | 26%
|