| WAR | Years | Pos | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 145.0 | 1905–1926 | OF | Ty Cobb | 95%
|
| 56.1 | 2005–2017 | P | Justin Verlander | 85%
|
| 49.0 | 2008–2023 | 3B | Miguel Cabrera | 85%
|
| 92.9 | 1953–1974 | OF | Al Kaline | 83%
|
| 70.7 | 1977–1996 | SS | Alan Trammell | 78%
|
| 75.1 | 1977–1995 | 2B | Lou Whitaker | 72%
|
| 52.8 | 1930–1941 1945–1946 | 1B | Hank Greenberg | 69%
|
| 84.8 | 1924–1942 | 2B | Charlie Gehringer | 53%
|
| 46.9 | 1963–1975 | P | Mickey Lolich | 50%
|
| 61.4 | 1939–1953 | P | Hal Newhouser | 49%
|
| 51.7 | 1960–1974 | 1B | Norm Cash | 47%
|
| 44.8 | 1961–1976 | C | Bill Freehan | 41%
|
| 68.1 | 1914–1929 | OF | Harry Heilmann | 32%
|
| 63.7 | 1903–1917 | OF | Sam Crawford | 32%
|
| 49.0 | 1939–1952 | P | Dizzy Trout | 15%
|
| 46.0 | 1912–1923 | OF | Bobby Veach | 11%
|
| 40.7 | 1912–1926 | P | Hooks Dauss | 7%
|
| 50.5 | 1930–1946 | P | Tommy Bridges | 7%
|
| 38.5 | 1908–1921 | SS | Donie Bush | 6%
|
| 46.4 | 1902–1913 | P | George Mullin | 6%
|