| Nickname | Tenure | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mookie | 2020– | Markus "Mookie" Betts | 96%
|
| Pee Wee | 1940–1942, 1946–1958 | Harold "Pee Wee" Reese | 85%
|
| The Claw | 2008– | Clayton Kershaw | 83%
|
| The Left Arm of God | 1955–1966 | Sandy Koufax | 83%
|
| Gibby | 1988–1990 | Kirk Gibson | 78%
|
| Dusty | 1976–1983 | Johnnie "Dusty" Baker | 75%
|
| The Silver Fox / The Duke of Flatbush | 1947–1962 | Edwin "Duke" Snider | 61%
|
| Campy | 1948–1957 | Roy Campanella | 61%
|
| EL Toro | 1980–1990 | Fernando Valenzuela | 55%
|
| Red | 2014–2022 | Justin Turner | 51%
|
| Ferris | 2017–2024 | Walker Buehler | 49%
|
| Bulldog | 1983–1994, 2000 | Orel Hershiser | 47%
|
| Billy Buck | 1969–1976 | Bill Buckner | 46%
|
| Big D | 1956–1969 | Don Drysdale | 42%
|
| Dazzy | 1922–1932, 1935 | Charles "Dazzy" Vance | 37%
|
| El Culichi | 2016–2023 | Julio Urías | 37%
|
| The Penguin | 1971–1982 | Ron Cey | 34%
|
| Popeye / Zim / Gerbil | 1954–1959, 1963 | Don Zimmer | 24%
|
| The Tornado | 1995–1998, 2002–2004 | Hideo Nomo | 22%
|
| 3-Dog | 1960–1973 | Willie Davis | 11%
|