| Team | WAR | Career | Pos | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Yankees | 142.7 | 1920–1934 | OF | Babe Ruth | 93%
|
| Giants | 112.5 | 1993–2007 | OF | Barry Bonds | 93%
|
| Angels | 87.5 | 2011– | OF | Mike Trout | 91%
|
| Giants | 154.6 | 1951–1952, 1954–1972 | OF | Willie Mays | 91%
|
| Braves | 142.5 | 1954–1974 | OF | Hank Aaron | 88%
|
| Marlins | 25.7 | 2005–2011 | P | Josh Johnson | 86%
|
| Diamondbacks | 50.9 | 1999–2004, 2007–2008 | P | Randy Johnson | 86%
|
| Twins/Senators | 165.1 | 1907–1927 | P | Walter Johnson | 86%
|
| Orioles | 95.9 | 1981–2001 | SS | Cal Ripken | 84%
|
| Yankees | 110.2 | 1951–1968 | OF | Mickey Mantle | 84%
|
| Yankees | 113.8 | 1923–1939 | 1B | Lou Gehrig | 83%
|
| Dodgers | 80.9 | 2008– | P | Clayton Kershaw | 82%
|
| Mariners | 70.6 | 1989–1999, 2009–2010 | OF | Ken Griffey Jr. | 82%
|
| Reds | 75.1 | 1967–1983 | C | Johnny Bench | 81%
|
| Astros | 53.4 | 2011– | 2B | Jose Altuve | 81%
|
| Red Sox | 121.8 | 1939–1942, 1946–1960 | OF | Ted Williams | 81%
|
| Padres | 69.2 | 1982–2001 | OF | Tony Gwynn | 81%
|
| Tigers | 145.0 | 1905–1926 | OF | Ty Cobb | 80%
|
| Orioles | 78.4 | 1955–1977 | 3B | Brooks Robinson | 79%
|
| Phillies | 106.8 | 1972–1989 | 3B | Mike Schmidt | 79%
|
| Royals | 88.6 | 1973–1993 | 3B | George Brett | 78%
|
| Pirates | 120.3 | 1900–1917 | SS | Honus Wagner | 78%
|
| Cardinals | 128.6 | 1941–1944, 1946–1963 | OF | Stan Musial | 78%
|
| Mets | 78.8 | 1967–1976 | P | Tom Seaver | 78%
|
| Athletics | 72.7 | 1979–1984, 1989–1992, 1994–1995, 1998 | OF | Rickey Henderson | 77%
|
| Brewers | 77.4 | 1974–1993 | SS / OF | Robin Yount | 76%
|
| Red Sox | 80.8 | 1984–1996 | P | Roger Clemens | 76%
|
| Padres | 27.2 | 2019– | OF/SS | Fernando Tatis Jr. | 75%
|
| Reds | 78.0 | 1963–1978, 1984–1986 | various | Pete Rose | 75%
|
| Pirates | 94.8 | 1955–1972 | OF | Roberto Clemente | 75%
|
| Cardinals | 89.1 | 1959–1975 | P | Bob Gibson | 74%
|
| Red Sox | 96.5 | 1961–1983 | OF | Carl Yastrzemski | 74%
|
| White Sox | 68.3 | 1990–2005 | 1B | Frank Thomas | 74%
|
| Mariners | 56.4 | 2001–2011, 2018–2019 | OF | Ichiro Suzuki | 73%
|
| Rangers | 50.0 | 1991–2002, 2009 | C | Iván Rodríguez | 73%
|
| Astros | 79.9 | 1991–2005 | 1B | Jeff Bagwell | 72%
|
| Astros | 65.5 | 1988–2007 | 2B | Craig Biggio | 71%
|
| Mariners | 68.4 | 1987–2004 | DH | Edgar Martinez | 71%
|
| Brewers | 47.1 | 2007–2020 | OF | Ryan Braun | 71%
|
| Rockies | 61.8 | 1997–2013 | 1B | Todd Helton | 69%
|
| Cubs | 67.7 | 1953–1971 | 3B/1B | Ernie Banks | 68%
|
| Mets | 49.2 | 2004–2016, 2018 | 3B | David Wright | 67%
|
| Rays | 51.2 | 2008–2017 | 3B | Evan Longoria | 66%
|
| Twins/Senators | 60.5 | 1954–1975 | Various | Harmon Killebrew | 66%
|
| Orioles | 68.5 | 1965–1967, 1969–1984 | P | Jim Palmer | 66%
|
| Diamondbacks | 39.9 | 2011–2018 | 1B | Paul Goldschmidt | 66%
|
| Marlins | 35.7 | 2010–2017 | OF | Giancarlo Stanton | 65%
|
| Tigers | 92.8 | 1953–1974 | OF | Al Kaline | 64%
|
| Rockies | 40.1 | 2013–2020 | 3B | Nolan Arenado | 64%
|
| Rangers | 41.1 | 2011–2018 | 3B | Adrian Beltre | 63%
|
| Nationals/Expos | 55.8 | 1974–1984, 1992 | C | Gary Carter | 63%
|
| Rockies | 48.3 | 1995–2004 | OF | Larry Walker | 63%
|
| Phillies | 69.4 | 1972–1986 | P | Steve Carlton | 63%
|
| Braves | 94.0 | 1952–1966 | 3B | Eddie Matthews | 62%
|
| Diamondbacks | 33.1 | 2017– | 2B | Ketel Marte | 62%
|
| Cubs | 68.0 | 1982–1994, 1996–1997 | 2B | Ryne Sandberg | 62%
|
| Mets | 46.4 | 1984–1994 | P | Dwight Gooden | 61%
|
| Brewers | 59.9 | 1978–1992 | 3B | Paul Molitor | 61%
|
| Blue Jays | 48.0 | 1998–2009 | P | Roy Halladay | 61%
|
| Twins/Senators | 63.8 | 1967–1978 | 2B | Rod Carew | 59%
|
| Cardinals | 91.5 | 1915–1926 | 2B | Rogers Hornsby | 59%
|
| Blue Jays | 38.3 | 2008–2017 | OF | José Bautista | 56%
|
| Dodgers | 68.4 | 1940–1942, 1946–1958 | SS | Pee Wee Reese | 56%
|
| Reds | 70.5 | 1986–2004 | SS | Barry Larkin | 55%
|
| Guardians/Indians | 63.5 | 1936–1941, 1945–1956 | P | Bob Feller | 55%
|
| Guardians/Indians | 79.6 | 1902–1914 | 2B | Nap Lajoie | 55%
|
| Braves | 99.3 | 1942, 1946–1964 | P | Warren Spahn | 53%
|
| Giants | 110.9 | 1926–1947 | OF | Mel Ott | 50%
|
| Cubs | 72.1 | 1960–1973 | 3B | Ron Santo | 48%
|
| Dodgers | 67.1 | 1956–1969 | P | Don Drysdale | 46%
|
| Athletics | 64.8 | 1925–1993 | P | Lefty Grove | 45%
|
| Nationals/Expos | 48.4 | 1976–1986 | OF | Andre Dawson | 44%
|
| Blue Jays | 56.8 | 1979–1992, 1998 | P | Dave Stieb | 44%
|
| Rangers | 44.6 | 1989–1993, 1999–2003 | 1B | Rafael Palmeiro | 43%
|
| Marlins | 26.9 | 2006–2011 | SS | Hanley Ramirez | 41%
|
| Guardians/Indians | 74.9 | 1916–1926 | OF | Tris Speaker | 40%
|
| Nationals/Expos | 49.1 | 1979–1990 | OF | Tim Raines | 37%
|
| Rays | 35.6 | 2002–2010 | OF | Carl Crawford | 35%
|
| Tigers | 84.8 | 1924–1942 | 2B | Charlie Gehringer | 35%
|
| Padres | 32.0 | 1973–1980 | OF | Dave Winfield | 35%
|
| Phillies | 72.0 | 1948–1961 | P | Robin Roberts | 35%
|
| White Sox | 77.5 | 1930–1943, 1945–1950 | SS | Luke Appling | 31%
|
| Pirates | 70.2 | 1926–1940 | OF | Paul Waner | 28%
|
| Angels | 51.8 | 1986–1999 | P | Chuck Finley | 21%
|
| Athletics | 77.2 | 1901–1914 | P | Eddie Plank | 20%
|
| Rays | 35.3 | 2006–2014 | SS | Ben Zobrist | 19%
|
| Royals | 44.8 | 1970–1983 | OF | Amos Otis | 18%
|
| Angels | 45.9 | 1961–1971 | SS | Jim Fregosi | 18%
|
| Royals | 47.0 | 1989–1999, 2003–2004 | P | Kevin Appier | 13%
|
| White Sox | 70.6 | 1923–1942, 1946 | P | Ted Lyons | 13%
|