| Player | Tenure | Nickname | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Bambino / The Sultan of Swat | 1920–1934 | Babe Ruth | 100%
|
| The Mick | 1951–1968 | Mickey Mantle | 97%
|
| Mr. November / The Captain | 1995–2014 | Derek Jeter | 96%
|
| A-Rod | 2004–2016 | Alex Rodriguez | 93%
|
| Yogi | 1946–1963 | Lawrence "Yogi" Berra | 92%
|
| Mr. October | 1977–1981 | Reggie Jackson | 90%
|
| All Rise | 2016– | Aaron Judge | 89%
|
| Yankee Clipper / Joltin' Joe | 1936–1951 | Joe DiMaggio | 87%
|
| Mo / The Sandman | 1995–2013 | Mariano Rivera | 87%
|
| The Iron Horse / Biscuit Pants | 1923–1939 | Lou Gehrig | 84%
|
| Donnie Baseball | 1982–1995 | Don Mattingly | 82%
|
| Catfish | 1975–1979 | James "CatfIsh" Hunter | 77%
|
| Goose | 1978–1983 | Rich "Goose" Gossage | 72%
|
| Tex | 2009–2016 | Mark Teixeira | 68%
|
| Grandy Man | 2010–2013 | Curtis Granderson | 67%
|
| Godzilla | 2003–2009 | Hideki Matsui | 58%
|
| El Duque | 1998–2004 | Orlando Hernández | 50%
|
| Moose | 2001–2008 | Mike Mussina | 41%
|
| Louisiana Lightning / Gator | 1975–1988 | Ron Guidry | 41%
|
| Moose | 1954–1962 | Bill Skowron | 23%
|