| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Yankee who is generally considered to be the best player in MLB history | Babe Ruth | 98%
|
| Borough of New York City where Yankee Stadium is located | The Bronx | 88%
|
| Player who hit an AL record 62 home runs in 2022 | Aaron Judge | 83%
|
| Player who married Marilyn Monroe | Joe DiMaggio | 83%
|
| Player who retired in 2014 with more hits than anyone else in Yankees history | Derek Jeter | 80%
|
| Player who called himself the "luckiest man on the face of the Earth" in a 1939 farewell speech | Lou Gehrig | 80%
|
| Player who signed a $275 million contract in 2007, at the time the largest in MLB history | Alex Rodriguez | 76%
|
| Catcher known for his many famous quotes such as "a nickle ain't worth a dime anymore" | Yogi Berra | 76%
|
| Nickname for a series where the Yankees play the Mets | {Subway} Series | 74%
|
| Yankee who hit 372 home runs left-handed, and another 164 right-handed | Mickey Mantle | 70%
|
| 1970s-era slugger nicknamed Mr. October | Reggie Jackson | 69%
|
| Former closer who holds the all-time MLB record for saves | Mariano Rivera | 68%
|
| Former owner who purchased the team in 1973 for just $8.7 million | George Steinbrenner | 63%
|
| Player who hit 61 home runs in 1961 - but saw his record tainted by an asterisk | Roger Maris | 61%
|
| Manager who led the Yankees to four World Series titles from 1996–2000 | Joe Torre | 60%
|
| Nickname of the Yankees batting lineup in the 1920s | {Murderer}'s Row | 58%
|
| Pitcher of the 1950s and 1960s who holds the team record for most wins | Whitey Ford | 44%
|
| Six-time All Star from the 1980s who was benched for refusing to trim his mullet | Don Mattingly | 42%
|
| Catcher who died in a plane crash in 1979 | Thurman Munson | 42%
|
| Manager who was fired by that owner five different times between 1975 and 1988 | Billy Martin | 38%
|