| WAR | Years | Position | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 52.5 | 2003–2016 | DH | David Ortiz | 93%
|
| 121.8 | 1939–1942, 1946–1960 | OF | Ted Williams | 87%
|
| 53.5 | 1998–2004 | P | Pedro Martinez | 78%
|
| 96.4 | 1961–1983 | OF | Carl Yastrzemski | 68%
|
| 80.8 | 1984–1996 | P | Roger Clemens | 66%
|
| 71.9 | 1982–1992 | 3B | Wade Boggs | 59%
|
| 51.8 | 2006–2019 | 2B | Dustin Pedroia | 53%
|
| 66.7 | 1901–1909 | P | Cy Young | 45%
|
| 66.5 | 1972–1990 | OF | Dwight Evans | 29%
|
| 55.7 | 1907–1915 | OF | Tris Speaker | 20%
|