| Team | Year | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Yankees | 2007 | Alex Rodriguez | 100%
|
| Yankees | 2009 | Alex Rodriguez | 100%
|
| Expos | 1978 | Andre Dawson | 100%
|
| Expos | 1985 | Andre Dawson | 100%
|
| Blue Jays | 2013 | Edwin Encarnacion | 100%
|
| Mariners | 2019 | Edwin Encarnacion | 100%
|
| Browns | 1922 | Ken Williams | 100%
|
| Reds | 2002 | Aaron Boone | 67%
|
| Rangers | 2012 | Adrian Beltre | 67%
|
| Mariners | 2002 | Bret Boone | 67%
|
| Red Stockings | 1880 | Charley Jones | 67%
|
| Yankees | 1977 | Cliff Johnson | 67%
|
| Red Sox | 2008 | David Ortiz | 67%
|
| Dodgers | 2000 | Eric Karros | 67%
|
| Cardinals * | 1999 | Fernando Tatis | 67%
|
| Marlins | 1997 | Gary Sheffield | 67%
|
| Giants | 1925 | Hack Wilson | 67%
|
| Devil Rays | 2002 | Jared Sandberg | 67%
|
| Astros | 1994 | Jeff Bagwell | 67%
|
| Yankees | 1936 | Joe DiMaggio | 67%
|
| Astros | 1974 | Lee May | 67%
|
| Athletics | 1996 | Mark McGwire | 67%
|
| Cubs | 1996 | Sammy Sosa | 67%
|
| Tigers | 1955 | Al Kaline | 33%
|
| Athletics | 2024 | Brent Rooker | 33%
|
| Indians | 1993 | Carlos Baerga | 33%
|
| Red Sox | 1990 | Ellis Burks | 33%
|
| Cubs | 2008 | Jim Edmonds | 33%
|
| Blue Jays | 1993 | Joe Carter | 33%
|
| Red Sox | 2002 | Nomar Garciaparra | 33%
|
| Giants | 2011 | Pablo Sandoval | 33%
|
| Phillies | 2023 | Trea Turner | 33%
|
| Phillies | 1985 | Von Hayes | 33%
|
| Giants | 1973 | Willie McCovey | 33%
|
| Giants | 1977 | Willie McCovey | 33%
|
| Phillies | 1949 | Andy Seminick | 0%
|
| Giants | 2007 | Bengie Molina | 0%
|
| Red Sox | 1928 | Bill Regan | 0%
|
| Beaneaters | 1894 | Bobby Lowe | 0%
|
| Rangers | 2002 | Carl Everett | 0%
|
| Braves | 1989 | Dale Murphy | 0%
|
| Brewers | 1996 | Dave Nilsson | 0%
|
| Browns | 1890 | Ed Cartwright | 0%
|
| Yankees | 2022 | Gleyber Torres | 0%
|
| Giants | 1935 | Hank Leiber | 0%
|
| Pirates | 1894 | Jake Stenzel | 0%
|
| Pirates | 1995 | Jeff King | 0%
|
| Pirates | 1996 | Jeff King | 0%
|
| Senators | 1959 | Jim Lemon | 0%
|
| Angels | 2025 | Jo Adell | 0%
|
| Yankees | 1962 | Joe Pepitone | 0%
|
| Expos | 1973 | John Boccabella | 0%
|
| Expos | 2004 | Juan Rivera | 0%
|
| Giants | 2010 | Juan Uribe | 0%
|
| Devil Rays | 2006 | Julio Lugo | 0%
|
| Angels | 2012 | Kendrys Morales | 0%
|
| Ward's Wonders | 1890 | Lou Bierbauer | 0%
|
| Tigers | 2007 | Magglio Ordonez | 0%
|
| Cubs | 2002 | Mark Bellhorn | 0%
|
| Orioles | 2016 | Mark Trumbo | 0%
|
| Red Sox | 2023 | Masataka Yoshida | 0%
|
| Twins | 2009 | Michael Cuddyer | 0%
|
| Mariners | 2002 | Mike Cameron | 0%
|
| Expos | 1997 | Mike Lansing | 0%
|
| Reds | 1980 | Ray Knight | 0%
|
| Pirates | 2003 | Reggie Sanders | 0%
|
| Angels | 1966 | Rick Reichardt | 0%
|
| Tigers | 2025 | Riley Greene | 0%
|
| Giants | 1949 | Sid Gordon | 0%
|