| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Leader of the gang | Dutch van der Linde | 100%
|
| Main protagonist | Arthur Morgan | 99%
|
| Protagonist of the first game and epilogue | John Marston | 98%
|
| Son of the above | Jack Marston | 97%
|
| Wife of the above | Abigail Roberts | 95%
|
| Gang member and snitch | Micah Bell | 95%
|
| Widow that joins the gang and later becomes a bounty hunter | Sadie Adler | 94%
|
| Native american gang member | Charles Smith | 92%
|
| Gang member you have a drunk night out with | Lenny Summers | 92%
|
| Co-founder of the Van der Linde gang | Hosea Matthews | 90%
|
| Biggest city | Saint Denis | 90%
|
| Irish gang member | Sean McGuire | 90%
|
| Town in which you helped the above escape prison | Strawberry | 90%
|
| Lifelong enemies of the Van der Linde gang | O'Driscoll Boys | 89%
|
| Leader of gang above | Colm O'Driscoll | 88%
|
| Old drunk gang member | Uncle | 88%
|
| Butcher of the gang | Simon Pearson | 87%
|
| Detective Agency hired to bring the Van der Linde gang to justice | Pinkerton National Detective Agency | 85%
|
| Small livestock town located in the Heartlands region of New Hanover | Valentine | 84%
|
| Rich entrepreneur the Van der Linde gang continuously robs | Leviticus Cornwall | 81%
|
| Main Agent of the above | Andrew Milton | 79%
|
| Town you can't visit during the majority of the game | Blackwater | 79%
|
| Main settlement where the family feud takes place | Rhodes | 73%
|
| One of the families of the above | Gray Family | 70%
|
| The other family | Braithwaite Family | 69%
|
| Son of the above | Eagle Flies | 68%
|
| State in which the above city is located | Lemoyne | 67%
|
| Chief of the Wapiti Indians | Rains Fall | 66%
|
| Wealthy Italian businessman and crime boss, operating in above city | Angelo Bronte | 63%
|
| Old flame of main protagonist | Mary Linton | 56%
|
| South-West State | New Austin | 54%
|