| # | Years | Team | Player | % Correct | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | +507 | 1969-84 | PHI | Bobby Clarke | 100%
|
| 2 | +582 | 1966-79 | BOS | Bobby Orr | 100%
|
| 3 | +527 | 1979-01 | BOS | Ray Bourque | 100%
|
| 4 | +520 | 1979-99 | EDM | Wanye Gretzky | 100%
|
| 7 | +456 | 1973-88 | NYI | Dennis Potvin | 95%
|
| 11 | +446 | 1971-91 | MTL | Guy Lafleur | 95%
|
| 15 | +380 | 1977-87 | NYI | Mike Bossy | 95%
|
| 1 | +722 | 1972-92 | MTL | Larry Robinson | 90%
|
| 9 | +449 | 1975-94 | NYI | Bryan Trottier | 85%
|
| 8 | +450 | 1991-12 | DET | Nicklas Lidström | 85%
|
| 13 | +395 | 1982-04 | NJD | Scott Stevens | 85%
|
| 6 | +462 | 1966-83 | MTL | Serge Savard | 45%
|
| 14 | +394 | 1972-85 | MTL | Steve Shutt | 45%
|
| 12 | +400 | 1979-95 | PHI | Mark Howe | 35%
|
| 10 | +448 | 1979-97 | PHI | Brad McCrimmon | 10%
|