| Population | Island | State/Territory | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8,063,232 | Long Island | New York | 95%
|
| 1,672,628 | Manhattan | New York | 95%
|
| 495,747 | Staten Island | New York | 93%
|
| 1,016,508 | Oahu | Hawaii | 91%
|
| 200,629 | Hawaii (Big Island) | Hawaii | 88%
|
| 154,100 | Maui | Hawaii | 81%
|
| 3,285,874 | Puerto Rico | ______ ____ | 72%
|
| 153,836 | Guam | ____ | 58%
|
| 73,214 | Kauai | Hawaii | 58%
|
| 54,774 | Galveston Island | Texas | 42%
|
| 41,004 | Saint Croix | US Virgin Islands | 40%
|
| 42,261 | Saint Thomas | US Virgin Islands | 40%
|
| 38,403 | Hilton Head Island | South Carolina | 35%
|
| 60,109 | Aquidneck Island | Rhode Island | 28%
|
| 43,385 | Saipan | Northern Mariana Islands | 28%
|
| 25,748 | Mercer Island | Washington | 26%
|
| 64,116 | Alameda Island | California | 21%
|
| 69,501 | Whidbey Island | Washington | 19%
|
| 48,878 | Tutuila | American Samoa | 9%
|
| 53,696 | Absecon Island | New Jersey | 5%
|