| Description | Character | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Journalist committed to Briarcliff Manor under false pretenses for trying to expose its secrets | Lana Winters | 100%
|
| Briarcliff inmate falsely accused of the Bloody Face killings | Kit Walker | 94%
|
| Stern nun with a shady past who oversees the doctors and patients at Briarcliff Manor | Sister Jude Martin | 94%
|
| Young nun working at the Briarcliff Manor who is possessed by the Devil himself | Sister Mary Eunice | 88%
|
| Court-appointed psychiatrist with a dark secret brought to Briarcliff Manor to assess a suspected serial killer's competency to stand trial | Dr. Oliver Thredson | 87%
|
| Playful microcephalic inmate at Briarcliff Manor and former performer in a freak show | Pepper | 86%
|
| French patient at Briarcliff Manor accused of murdering her family and lover of ^ | Grace Bertrand | 82%
|
| Secretly married to #4 due to racial tensions before she was abducted by aliens | Alma Walker | 77%
|
| Chief physician at Briarcliff Manor and Nazi war criminal | Dr. Arthur Arden | 74%
|
| Director of the Briarcliff Manor Sanitarium and a man of the cloth | Monsignor Timothy Howard | 68%
|
| Benevolent entity that appears to administer the kiss of death to dying individuals | The Angel of Death | 61%
|
| Illicit girlfriend of #1 and 3rd grade teacher | Wendy Peyser | 59%
|
| One of the inmates at Briarcliff Manor serving a sentence, but committed no crime | Shelley | 39%
|
| Head of Security at Briarcliff Manor | Frank McCann | 37%
|
| Inmate of Briarcliff and serial killer who murders his victims dressed as Santa Clause | Leigh Emerson | 33%
|